No I can't. But Halliday is just one person, not everyone has to agree with his opinion. And indeed many don't. Your response implies that Halliday is the only or best judge of good wine.
Yes - if it's not, then you could always return or gift the remainderIs this wine as good as it sounds!?
Traditionally, the 100yo Seppeltsfield Para Vintage Tawny
So how much do Nick Stock/James Suckling's 100 and Gary Walsh's 97 contribute?But as a general principle my taste does not 100% align with his and there are other wine critics who's scores I rate higher because they better align with my tastes. Don't get me wrong I think this is a very good wine. But the fact that Halliday rates it 100 probably contributes about 10% of less in making that assessment.
Fortified | Non Vintage
Yes, I'd agree with that.97 points are not to be taken lightly, mofos! This cabernet has earned every one, though. It’s an incredible display of terroir and masterful winemaking, wit...www.vinomofo.com
Rosenthal Collector Mount Barker Cabernet Sauvignon ?
Reviewed by CM for Halliday
or $43.23 using a free $40 gift card as well:
$699-$899 delivered @ My Wine Guy (before $30 voucher )Traditionally, the 100yo Seppeltsfield Para Vintage Tawny
89-92 last 5 vintages on JH (no 2014 review). Made by Hollick Estates.One of our favourite wineries in Coonawarra is back with another vintage of their wondrous Bordeaux blend. Apparently, the 2014 growing season was one of the...www.vinomofo.com
'Secret', apart from the fact they mention the wine in the description
In the winery, the grapes were handled carefully to retain the individual fruit flavours which were developed in the vineyard. Partial barrel fermentation followed by 18 months maturation in French oak barrels (20% new) has given the 2014 Tannery Block an elegant structure and a long finish.
Suspect Tar & Roses Heathcote Nebbiolo
And my first post here and recently started ordering from vinomofo. If anyone knows some good value reds on here they can point me to, thats very welcome!
Hi Aaardvark,And my first post here and recently started ordering from vinomofo. If anyone knows some good value reds on here they can point me to, thats very welcome!