I’m well aware that this is a Qantas thread but I’ve seen “comparison” posts on here before and usually find them quite interesting to see. There once used to be a thread on trans-Tasman service comparison in particular which I used to be very active on but I can’t find it for the life of me. So mods- please move if you must!
I’ll keep it on the food though- wanted to book Qantas SYD-AKL while they offered a “special” which turned out to be roughly the same as all the competing airlines but the flight times that I actually needed, of course were roughly double that and on these tired old 737s. So despite my usually way too close loyalty to Qantas, I made the plunge. Especially knowing that QF’s trans Tasman service has been downgraded to “Domestic plus proper champagne” since the pandemic.
So- just for reference, Air NZ (on the outbound) still serves the proper 3 course International meal that it always did. Awful coffin seats (though they are, as slowly as Qantas would, finally getting rid of those) but still better than any 737 recliner. Menu and two photos below:

^^^Yes, this is garlic bread rather than the same old boring “plain or seeded sourdough”. And yes, this is me voluntarily going for the fish dish as a starter- NZ smoked salmon got me back to trying fish in rare cases and this one was as delightful as ever. Tassie salmon does not even come close in my experience (sorry to all the Tassie salmon lovers but it tends to taste about three times as fishy which is definitely not for me). The lamb main was rather disappointing given NZ’s reputation for lamb, lots of fat and inedible shoe-sole style meat. Not good but the potatos and grilled eggplant on the side were good. And it was properly presented- not just some Domestic slop like what Qantas usually does these days on this route:
But, probably more interesting, on my way back after three delightful nights at one of my favourite hotels in the Southern Hemisphere, the Park Hyatt Auckland, I chose China Eastern. After some really great flights domestically within China on various airlines a year ago, I was curious to see how this would go on the trans Tasman. Plus- this was a rare chance to practice my shaky Mandarin so what’s not to love! Aircraft was a 13yo old A330ceo with lie flat but older style seats in 2-2-2 configuration (pretty much the exact same product as LATAM has on the non refurbished older 787s). Now- many people call the crews on mainland China carriers robotic but I’ve never felt this way but maybe that’s me speaking a tiny bit of Chinese since I spent half my childhood living in Singapore? I don’t know. I found the crew to be a delight and my stuttering Mandarin (while looking like the most Germanic person you can imagine- beer tummy and blonde hair included) certainly helped.
The meal consisted of a proper starter (unfortunately prawns, which I really can’t eat without an instant vomit attack) and then a choice of 4 (!) different mains, presented on a hand held post-it note in both Chinese and English. I asked whether the pork or the beef would be the Chinese dish (vego and scallops being the other, not considered options) and was enthusiastically assured that the beef was very spicy and authentic. What I then really got (together with a choice of bread, including a rather stale garlic bread) was essentially a Chinese goulash. Very spicy indeed but it still reminded me more of Budapest than Shanghai. But the best bit here: The meat quality! Qantas- take note. It was amongst the best and most tender cubes of beef that were ever served on an airplane. I was stunned as I kind of got used to the cheap off cuts that NP selects as “only the finest produce” (yea-right!).
And before I forget- I asked for champagne and it was to die for! I had never heard of this (apparently inexpensive but hardly available) brand but it was a Haslinger &Fils from Epernay. No one else in this half empty J class cabin had any of it to my knowledge so I ended up gulping up the entire bottle over this 3 hour flight which strangely was always served in the same finger-printed glass. I always find it odd that on many airlines, you get a fresh glass with almost every refill but this was a bit too much of the same glass after a while. Oh well- down the hatch, and the stemmed champagne glass was actually rather lovely (as is the flower printed amenity kit and the cute little bags for the slippers with the red ribbons on it). Loved this entire flight!
