The Sam Kim score is actually 96:
Monterra
Reserve Shiraz 2017
Rating: 96
This is meltingly delicious; the gloriously fragrant bouquet shows dark fruit intensity with seductive notes of cake spice, mocha, cedar and game, followed by a sumptuous palate that is opulent and mouthfilling. Splendidly rich and robust with impressive power and persistency. At its best: now to 2030. AU$40.00.
www.monterrawines.com. Jan 2019.
Now listed at $50 at the winery.
2017 Reserve McLaren Vale Shiraz
No wonder I was confused, there is also a later 95pt note with the higher price...
Monterra
Reserve Shiraz 2017
Rating: 95
This is impressively fruited and immensely appealing on the nose showing blackberry, mixed berry compote, cocoa, tar and cedary oak characters, leading to a powerfully expressed palate that is concentrated and persistent. The wine offers terrific fruit richness backed by velvety texture and refined tannins. At its best: now to 2030. $50.00.
www.monterrawines.com. Aug 2019.
And Wine Direct also show the 94pt Wine Showcase score.