xONE4 split

Discussion in 'American Airlines AAdvantage' started by sparoy, Apr 2, 2007.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
Welcome to Australia's leading independent Frequent Flyer and Travel Resource!
Our site contains tons of information that will improve your travel experience.
Joining AFF is fast, simple & ABSOLUTELY FREE -  join now by clicking on the JOIN NOW button, and take immediate advantage of these great BENEFITS.
Once registered, this box will disappear. And you will see fewer advertisements :)
  1. sparoy

    sparoy Member

    Apr 2, 2007
    178
    2
    Sydney
    Hi All,

    I've been reading this forum for a little while and learned a lot from it. We're planning to do a xONE4 trip, but like to structure it so we can have like a 2 trip in 1 year, ie USA this year and Europe/Asia next year. We want to do the AAdvantage platinum challenge at the same time. I'm using the Oneworld planner below, so there may be some bugs there.

    Round the World Planner Itinerary Details - 2007 RTW split
    9/07/2007 Through 30/06/2008
    ------------------------------------------------------------
    Total City Count: 18
    Total Sector Count: 19
    Total Region Count: 4
    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: Sydney, Australia (Kingsford Smith)
    Sectors: 2
    Flight details
    Depart: SYD - Sydney, Australia (Kingsford Smith)
    Arrive: BOS - Boston, United States (Logan)
    Via: LAX - Los Angeles, United States (Los Angeles)
    Leg 1:
    Depart: SYD 1:25p 9/07/2007 Terminal: 1
    Arrive: LAX 9:45a 9/07/2007 Terminal: 4
    Flight: AA 7363 - American Airlines
    744 - Boeing 747-400 Passenger
    Operating Carrier: Qantas Airways
    Connecting flight leaves in 3 hours 40 minutes
    Leg 2:
    Depart: LAX 1:25p 9/07/2007 Terminal: 4
    Arrive: BOS 9:55p 9/07/2007 Terminal: B
    Flight: AA 264 - American Airlines
    757 - Boeing 757 Passenger
    Operating Carrier: American Airlines
    Total Duration: 22 hours 30 minutes

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: Boston, United States (Logan)
    Sectors: 2
    Flight details
    Depart: BOS - Boston, United States (Logan)
    Arrive: SLC - Salt Lake City, United States (Salt Lake City)
    Via: DFW - Dallas, United States (Dallas/Ft. Worth)
    Leg 1:
    Depart: BOS 7:00a 17/07/2007 Terminal: B
    Arrive: DFW 9:55a 17/07/2007
    Flight: AA 631 - American Airlines
    M83 - Boeing (Douglas) MD-83
    Operating Carrier: American Airlines
    Connecting flight leaves in 50 minutes
    Leg 2:
    Depart: DFW 10:45a 17/07/2007 Terminal: C
    Arrive: SLC 12:20p 17/07/2007 Terminal: 1
    Flight: AA 1091 - American Airlines
    M80 - Boeing (Douglas) MD-80
    Operating Carrier: American Airlines
    Total Duration: 7 hours 20 minutes

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: Salt Lake City, United States (Salt Lake City)
    Sectors: 1
    *** No Flight Details ***

    No direct flight and will purchase separate ticket SLC - LAS

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: Las Vegas, United States (McCarran)
    Sectors: 1
    Flight details
    Depart: LAS - Las Vegas, United States (McCarran)
    Arrive: LAX - Los Angeles, United States (Los Angeles)
    Leg 1:
    Depart: LAS 6:35p 27/07/2007 Terminal: 1
    Arrive: LAX 7:45p 27/07/2007 Terminal: 4
    Flight: AA 3108 - American Airlines
    ERD - Embraer RJ140
    Operating Carrier: American Airlines
    Total Duration: 1 hours 10 minutes

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: Los Angeles, United States (Los Angeles)
    Sectors: 1
    *** No Flight Details ***

    LAX - SYD by award flight 27 Jul 07
    SYD - LAX by award flight 1 May 08
    continue xONE4 trip LAX - YVR 1 May 08 by AA on Air Alaska metal?
    Is it possible?

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: Vancouver, Canada (Vancouver)
    Sectors: 1
    Flight details
    Depart: YVR - Vancouver, Canada (Vancouver)
    Arrive: LHR - London, United Kingdom (Heathrow)
    Leg 1:
    Depart: YVR 8:30p 2/05/2008 Terminal: M
    Arrive: LHR 1:35p 3/05/2008 Terminal: 1
    Flight: BA 84 - British Airways
    747 - Boeing 747 Passenger
    Operating Carrier: British Airways
    Total Duration: 9 hours 5 minutes

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: London, United Kingdom (Heathrow)
    Sectors: 1
    Flight details
    Depart: LHR - London, United Kingdom (Heathrow)
    Arrive: ATH - Athens, Greece (Eleftherios Venizelos)
    Leg 1:
    Depart: LHR 12:25p 10/05/2008 Terminal: 1
    Arrive: ATH 6:05p 10/05/2008
    Flight: BA 632 - British Airways
    767 - Boeing 767 Passenger
    Operating Carrier: British Airways
    Total Duration: 3 hours 40 minutes

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: Athens, Greece (Eleftherios Venizelos)
    Sectors: 1
    *** No Flight Details ***

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: Budapest, Hungary (Ferihegy)
    Sectors: 1
    *** No Flight Details ***

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: Rome, Italy (Fiumicino)
    Sectors: 1
    Flight details
    Depart: FCO - Rome, Italy (Fiumicino)
    Arrive: HKG - Hong Kong, Hong Kong (Hong Kong)
    Leg 1:
    Depart: FCO 12:50p 29/05/2008 Terminal: C
    Arrive: HKG 6:25a 30/05/2008
    Flight: CX 292 - Cathay Pacific Airways
    744 - Boeing 747-400 Passenger
    Operating Carrier: Cathay Pacific Airways
    Total Duration: 11 hours 35 minutes

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: Hong Kong, Hong Kong (Hong Kong)
    Sectors: 1
    Flight details
    Depart: HKG - Hong Kong, Hong Kong (Hong Kong)
    Arrive: CGK - Jakarta, Indonesia (Soekarno-Hatta)
    Leg 1:
    Depart: HKG 9:20a 31/05/2008
    Arrive: CGK 1:05p 31/05/2008 Terminal: 2
    Flight: CX 777 - Cathay Pacific Airways
    343 - Airbus Industrie A340-300
    Operating Carrier: Cathay Pacific Airways
    Total Duration: 4 hours 45 minutes

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: Jakarta, Indonesia (Soekarno-Hatta)
    Sectors: 1
    Flight details
    Depart: CGK - Jakarta, Indonesia (Soekarno-Hatta)
    Arrive: NRT - Tokyo, Japan (Narita)
    Leg 1:
    Depart: CGK 10:10p 4/06/2008 Terminal: 2
    Arrive: NRT 7:25a 5/06/2008 Terminal: 2
    Flight: JL 726 - JAL
    777 - Boeing 777 Passenger
    Operating Carrier: JL for JO
    Total Duration: 7 hours 15 minutes

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: Tokyo, Japan (Narita)
    Sectors: 1
    Flight details
    Depart: NRT - Tokyo, Japan (Narita)
    Arrive: SIN - Singapore, Singapore (Changi)
    Leg 1:
    Depart: NRT 10:55a 6/06/2008 Terminal: 2
    Arrive: SIN 5:35p 6/06/2008 Terminal: 1
    Flight: JL 719 - JAL
    777 - Boeing 777 Passenger
    Operating Carrier: JAL
    Total Duration: 7 hours 40 minutes

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: Singapore, Singapore (Changi)
    Sectors: 1
    Flight details
    Depart: SIN - Singapore, Singapore (Changi)
    Arrive: SYD - Sydney, Australia (Kingsford Smith)
    Leg 1:
    Depart: SIN 8:00p 16/06/2008 Terminal: 1
    Arrive: SYD 6:50a 17/06/2008 Terminal: 1
    Flight: BA 15 - British Airways
    777 - Boeing 777 Passenger
    Operating Carrier: British Airways
    Total Duration: 7 hours 50 minutes

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: Sydney, Australia (Kingsford Smith)
    Sectors: 1
    Flight details
    Depart: SYD - Sydney, Australia (Kingsford Smith)
    Arrive: DRW - Darwin, Australia (Darwin)
    Leg 1:
    Depart: SYD 10:10a 27/06/2008 Terminal: 1
    Arrive: DRW 1:00p 27/06/2008
    Flight: QF 123 - Qantas Airways
    333 - Airbus Industrie A330-300
    Operating Carrier: Qantas Airways
    Total Duration: 4 hours 20 minutes

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: Darwin, Australia (Darwin)
    Sectors: 1
    Flight details
    Depart: DRW - Darwin, Australia (Darwin)
    Arrive: PER - Perth, Australia (Perth)
    Leg 1:
    Depart: DRW 2:20p 27/06/2008
    Arrive: PER 5:35p 27/06/2008 Terminal: 2
    Flight: QF 793 - Qantas Airways
    73H - Boeing 737-800 (winglets) Passenger
    Operating Carrier: Qantas Airways
    Total Duration: 3 hours 45 minutes

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: Perth, Australia (Perth)
    Sectors: 1
    Flight details
    Depart: PER - Perth, Australia (Perth)
    Arrive: SYD - Sydney, Australia (Kingsford Smith)
    Leg 1:
    Depart: PER 4:20p 30/06/2008 Terminal: 2
    Arrive: SYD 10:20p 30/06/2008 Terminal: 3
    Flight: QF 566 - Qantas Airways
    743 - Boeing 747-300 / 747-100/200 SUD Passenger
    Operating Carrier: Qantas Airways
    Total Duration: 4 hours 0 minutes

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    City: Sydney, Australia (Kingsford Smith)
    Sectors: 0

    ------------------------------------------------------------
    Warnings
    1. Flight date (27/06/2008) is on the same date as previous flight (27/06/2008)


    I like to have some comments from the experts regarding our itinerary. I'm tossing whether to do DONE4 or LONE4 with BA WT+ (how much extra?). I value my sleep and I can never get any reasonable sleep in long haul Y. I've never taken any long haul J. I've read that J in BA is very good for sleeping, that's why I try to use BA as much as possible. May be someone beg to differ?
    The European leg is still not fixed, but they are relatively short flights. Any comments on Malev?
    How do you overcome the problem of 1 transcontinental flight only in Australia? Can I only have less than 24hr transit in Darwin? I like to stay more than 24hr if possible.
    Thank you so much in advance.
     

  2. serfty

    Moderator

    Nov 16, 2004
    39,234
    7,755
    MEL
    Flight Map:
    View my flight map
    #2 serfty, Apr 2, 2007
    Last edited: Apr 2, 2007
    G'day sparoy, welcome to AFF.

    I'll answer a couple of queries.

    - Codeshares on non oneWORLD airlines are not permitted in an xONEx so that counts out having a LAX-YVR AA codeshare on AS.

    - You are only permitted two stopovers in your 'continent of origin' so you are looking at one at SYD and one a PER; to stay in DRW more than 24 hours would become a third stopover and the itinary would not comply with the rules.

    - As far as trans continentals go, one way is to travel PER-CBR, then a red e-deal to CBR-SYD on a separate ticket.
     
  3. NM

    NM
    Moderator

    Aug 27, 2004
    15,764
    1,214
    Flight Map:
    View my flight map
    To maximise the miles earning along with the Platinum Challenge, think abouot routing SYD-JFK-BOS instead of SYD-LAX-BOS. SYD-JFK is 9950 miles flown. So start in MEL and use the AA codeshare for MEL-SYD and SYD-JFK so that the SYD-JFK flight completes the challenge and hence earns the 100% platinum bonus for the 9950 miles flown.

    Of course, if you choose to purchase a DONE4, then it really does not matter since the SYD-LAX on a D fare will be enough to complete the challenge.

    On a L fare, SYD-LAX-BOS will complete the challange and earn you about 12,700 AA miles. On the same fare, MEL-SYD-JFK-BOS will earn you around 21,400 AA miles. Quite a bit better for the extra routing.
     
  4. sparoy

    sparoy Member

    Apr 2, 2007
    178
    2
    Sydney
    Thanks serfty.
    Are there any other options apart from purchasing separate fare LAX-YVR?
    I think I've used up my 6 NAM sectors, so even going say to SFO will be extra cost anyway and no guarantee will get to YVR on xONE4. I'm basically trying to avoid another transcontinental in NAM and also hate the non earning points USA to London. I was contemplating doing LAX-ORD-FRA instead.
     
  5. sparoy

    sparoy Member

    Apr 2, 2007
    178
    2
    Sydney
    Thanks NM
    On a L fare for MEL-SYD-JFK-BOS, do I have to take the AA codeshare for MEL-SYD on the same day/international connection as the SYD-JFK? Or can I have a couple of days rest in between? The JFK will be an extra sector, right?
     
  6. fursten

    fursten Junior Member

    Dec 9, 2006
    49
    4
    Melbourne
    Have I missed something?
    A Platinum Challenge must be done on AA metal or codeshare but the ticket must be bought and ticketed through AA.
    Fursten
     
  7. Dave Noble

    Dave Noble Senior Member

    Oct 10, 2005
    6,419
    8
    No. The flights that make up the challenge must be on AA flight numbers however there is no restriction on who issues the ticket

    Dave
     
  8. sparoy

    sparoy Member

    Apr 2, 2007
    178
    2
    Sydney
    Is it best to use book and pay using the AA desk for my itinerary? The AA Mascot office is not too far away, although I read somewhere they are not open to the public. How is the BA WT+ extra cost on LONE4 calculated? Is it by sector or as one fixed cost?
     
  9. NM

    NM
    Moderator

    Aug 27, 2004
    15,764
    1,214
    Flight Map:
    View my flight map
    The MEL-SYD will need to be on the AA codeshare but does not need to be the same day. But if it is not the same day, then you have used one of the two stopovers permitted in the continent of origin.
    I am not really sure what you mean here. To maximise the points earning, make sure you reach the 10,000 EQP on a flight with large miles earning, since you get the 100% platinum bonus on the qualifying flight. So make sure the SYD-JFK is a sngle flight number and single sector.
     
  10. sparoy

    sparoy Member

    Apr 2, 2007
    178
    2
    Sydney
    I was referring to SYD-JFK-BOS as having an extra sector/segment compared to SYD-LAX-BOS, but I just realised now that it doesn't use an extra sector/segment because SYD-JFK is a single sector and single flight number even though it stopover in LAX. Thanks NM
     
  11. Kiwi Flyer

    Kiwi Flyer Senior Member

    Sep 24, 2004
    5,453
    4
    The surcharge for WT+ is per flight. Sorry I don't have rules on me to provide the amount.
     
  12. Dave Noble

    Dave Noble Senior Member

    Oct 10, 2005
    6,419
    8
    The WT+ charge per segment for flights other than single segment LHR-SYD is USD300/AUD450 and for LHR-SYD it is USD450/AUD900

    The AUD amount ( or NZD equivalent ) is charged for tickets issued in AUD or NZD and the USD amount ( or equivalent) charged otherwise

    Dave
     
  13. sparoy

    sparoy Member

    Apr 2, 2007
    178
    2
    Sydney
    Thanks Dave.
    It's probably a question with many answers, but has anyone ever calculated the difference in value between DONE4, LONE4 with BA WT+ & LONE4 in a split RTW trip? I mean sure there's a big difference in cost, but are you getting a good value out of a DONE4? Comparing the comfort level etc, higher points accumulations and splitting it in 2 trips seems not a bad option, just like getting 2 for the price of 1.
    If you factor in the 100% Platinum bonus then it can be more attractive as some OW carriers give little or nil points in L but all give 150% in D? Just wondering what would be the potential difference in points between them? (Take my itinerary as an example)
     
  14. serfty

    Moderator

    Nov 16, 2004
    39,234
    7,755
    MEL
    Flight Map:
    View my flight map
    DONE4's are generally regarded as giving the best Status/Points etc for you Buck; wether it be with AA, BA or QF Frequent Flyer Program.

    In 2005 I commenced a DONE4 from CMB, Did Japan, Hong Kong & NZ then to Oz (MEL). In Dec I did Oz. Mar 2006 I went to London and Dubai, ending in LAX from where I came home to MEL. In June I went back to LAX and did the US, ending up in HKG. Then I came home again. In August I went back to HKG, and completed the DONE4 be going back to CMB.

    Aside from positioning trips to/from CMB and the DONE 4 I split the trip with LAX-MEL-LAX, HKG-MEL-HKG.

    The DONE4 directly earned 2360 QFF SC's, when split over two QFF "years" and combined with my business travel enabled WP for two years.
     
  15. moa999

    moa999 Senior Member

    Jun 23, 2003
    9,046
    1,672
    Sydney
    Flight Map:
    View my flight map
    DONE4 generally regarded as better for SC/$ on QF.

    Prices depending on where you start are 3-4x the LONE, yet it earns 4x SCs J flights, and 6x SCs on the AA domestic segments.

    Definitely better comfort-wise, although you do need to pick your routes.

    The LONEs would work out better for FFP/$, but most on this board are more concerned about the SCs
     
  16. sparoy

    sparoy Member

    Apr 2, 2007
    178
    2
    Sydney
    Thanks guys for all the replies.
    Now, if only I can convince mrs sparoy to see the value in the same way..;)

    I read a lot of discussions of CMB being the cheapest location to start DONE4. I may not be in the position to do that this time, but will definitely consider it for the next DONE4.

    Has anyone got the current pricing for DONE4 ex CGK (Jakarta) and any experience starting from there? It might be more suitable for me in the future.

    sparoy
     
  17. Skyring

    Skyring Established Member

    Oct 18, 2005
    1,972
    1,316
    Canberra, Australia
    Flight Map:
    View my flight map
    This is pretty much my thinking. Comfort aside.

    I'd have to do 4 or 5 LONE4 trips to get the same SC earn as a single well-planned DONE4. I don't have the time (or money) to do 4 LONE4s in a year (given that for each one I'd be down ten day's worth of earning, plus the cost of accommodation, and a whole set of taxes each time), but I can certainly do a DONE4.
     
  18. futaris

    futaris Established Member

    Jul 21, 2006
    2,879
    117
    Brisbane
    Ultimate global A/D/LONE3/4/5/6 pricing - FlyerTalk Forums

    I'm not sure that you'll be able to get pricing of the xONE4's from CGK easily, without going through a travel agent. In any case, if you find out, please let me/us know.

    Of course it should be easy to find a fare flying from somewhere else in SE asia, i.e. SIN.
     
  19. serfty

    Moderator

    Nov 16, 2004
    39,234
    7,755
    MEL
    Flight Map:
    View my flight map
    Done4 - 60200300 (idr)

    (aud8188)
     
  20. futaris

    futaris Established Member

    Jul 21, 2006
    2,879
    117
    Brisbane
    And the LONE4?
     
Loading...

Share This Page