Virgin terrified of Jetstar/QF plans

Discussion in 'Open Discussion' started by jakeseven7, Dec 15, 2005.

Tags:
  1. jakeseven7

    jakeseven7 Active Member

    Sep 9, 2005
    560
    19
    Just had a rather interesting chat with an snr mgr at Virgin Blue... over a couple of beers his tongue got a bit loose...!

    Basically with all the QF announcements - massive new fleet orders, Jetstar to NZ, linking up with Jetstar Asia, a two class Jetstar international airline, all this allowing the main QF brand to concentrate on more business routes - combined with the ownership struggle @ Patrick really has VB exec team more than a little nervous...

    He said no one, including Brett Godfrey expected such a large, 'cumbersome' company such as QF to be able to respond so strategically to VB. They all had Jetstar tagged as a total non threat to begin with and realise now they should have taken it more seriously now Jetstar has positioned itself as the real budget airline in Australia and eroding VB's once core target market. This has left VB uneasily trapped in the middle between a rapidly growing Jetstar and a solid Qantas.

    The sales/marketing team are terrified that VB has lost its differentiation in the market as it creeps closer to Qantas in price without offering anywhere near the frequency or services and Jetstar is now widely known as the cheapest airfare so picks up the leisure travellers.
    Registered Users don't see this and have the option of removing all other advertisements.  Register HERE

    Interestingly the general feel at Virgin is that Velocity is being marketed badly and is a bit of a 'we had to have one so someone has slapped this together in a week or so' feel about it.

    Hedging - don't even go there... Staff can't beleive that fuel was not hedged. It is a banned topic @ HQ! Pacific Blue isn't really talked about either, it started as a bit of a 'keep the air fair' idealistic thing but nobody at Virgin realised how tough the trans tasman / pacific was going to be - and as we know they haven't made a dime out of the extension (infact have lost money). Quote 'even bloody air pacific is sticking the boot in, via qantas of course!'

    Having said all that Virgin are desperately trying to win back the media who have been busy picking apart their balance sheet over the last couple of years. They reckon if they get Branson back it will be a boost but realise that even Branson has some work to do after his latest stunt to promote Virgin Atlantic @ Bondi was largely ignored by the media. Virgin believe the one key thing they have left is their brand's attitude.

    Thought this was all rather interesting coming from an insider!
    If you are planning to have a go and accuse me of makingthis up, please don't bother but would love to hear others thoughts on it..

    IS Virgin in real trouble? ;-) Or just a tough patch?!

    Cheers /
     
  2. thadocta

    thadocta Active Member

    Wot he said.

    Dave
     
  3. JohnK

    JohnK Veteran Member

    Mar 22, 2005
    37,611
    7,514
    BNE, SYD and CNX
    Very interesting comments.

    I think Virgin will survive especially if Branson is back again.

    International 2 class flights reasonably priced will give them a small share of the market. I don't think they can compete with the Qantas monopoly but certainly can compete to a certain extent with Jetstar. Just need to choose their initial routes carefully. We have seen the problems, with O7, than can occur when trying to start up a new airline.

    I think Velocity is a reasonable start for a new frequent flyer program. Adding decent partners to this program will make it more attractive to some people.
     
  4. JohnK

    JohnK Veteran Member

    Mar 22, 2005
    37,611
    7,514
    BNE, SYD and CNX
    Very interesting comments from the senior manager at Virgin.

    I think Virgin will survive especially if Branson is back again.

    International 2 class flights reasonably priced will give them a small share of the market. I don't think they can compete with the Qantas monopoly but certainly can compete to a certain extent with Jetstar. Just need to choose their initial routes carefully. We have seen the problems, with O7, than can occur when trying to start up a new airline.

    I think Velocity is a reasonable start for a new frequent flyer program. Adding decent partners to this program will make it more attractive to some people.
     
  5. QF WP

    Moderator

    Jun 20, 2002
    14,240
    5,926
    Brisbane
    Flight Map:
    View my flight map
    Twitter:
    Facebook:
    Linkedin:
    Might have to follow up with Brett and another very senior manager I know about the truth or validity of some of this information...

    Interesting, nonetheless...
     
  6. N860CR

    N860CR Established Member

    Nov 30, 2004
    3,059
    651
    Brisbane & Sydney
    I think Virgin are going fine, they are still the better of the two LCC's in Australia and have substancially better public support. Jetstar Domestic is growing, yes, but more through force than choice. Virgin probably didn't expect them to still be around (same way I feel), however with Qantas dropping a number of routes, people have been forced to use Jetstar and hence ensured its sucess.

    It's worth noting that JetstarAsia hasn't had anywhere near the sucess of Jetstar here. There is a lot of competition over there, where as in Australia people basically take whatever seat they can get (because there isn't always too many of them).

    Pacific Blue is still developing and Jetstar's NZ routes will probably have the same issues. It's evidently harder to get costs down on some of these routes, FJ and DJ charge basically the same fares SYD-NAN, however DJ has undercut QF and NZ on the trans-tasman flights. It needs time to grow.

    Should Branson take control again it will put Virgin in a better long term position, however for 2006 I'd say the airline will just work on strengthening its current strong market position.
     
  7. Yada Yada

    Yada Yada Established Member

    Dec 6, 2004
    1,872
    8
    1F
    As someone who has flown more DJ than QF domestically this year, I'd say they are still doing OK. They have turned a decent profit despite not having hedged fuel pricing, and with JQ having eaten into their LCC market, and with SYD airport costs having gone through the roof.

    Whenever I fly SYD-MEL or SYD-BNE, DJ planes are almost entirely full, so they certainly do not have the problem that O7 has. The peak hour scheduling on the routes I travel are the equal of QF. Although on a recent trip to ADL I flew QF because the schedule suited me better than DJ's.

    I wonder if the comments you heard indicate not so much actual problems at DJ but are more perceived problems. Perhaps a recent loss of mindshare is affecting them? QF/JQ have been making all the news lately with aircraft purchases and launching new services and routes etc, which probably makes DJ feel that they are being left behind. DJ have been the ones making all this type of news for the past 5 years - regular new aircraft arrivals, new services domestically and OS etc. However they have now reached a stage where they are consolidating and therefore have fewer announcements. The corporate duelling going on between Patrick and Toll cannot be helping their attitude either. The sooner this is resolved the better.

    I'm not so sure they should fear JQ. There are major differences between the two and I'm not sure DJ would want to mimic them. They'd be better off continuing to improve their business offerings while keeping costs contained. JQ does not even fly to MEL so IMO they are a side player in one of the biggest sectors in the country. And they are much smaller in fleet and pax numbers right now.

    Getting Branson back would be good even just from the point of view of having a charismatic and cheeky figurehead back in place.
     
  8. NM

    NM
    Moderator

    Aug 27, 2004
    15,698
    1,179
    Flight Map:
    View my flight map
    Very interesting comments from an insider (no reason to believe you are making it all up). I can understand the thinking. Whether it is true or not is less of an issue, but perceptions are realities in many cases.

    I think Qantas got a wakeup call when DJ went through its rapid expansion. They really under-estimated the threat from DJ. Now it appears the pendulum may have swung back the other way.
     
  9. markis10

    markis10 Veteran Member

    Nov 25, 2004
    30,088
    5,547
    BNE & SYD
    Cheap fares attract business travellers as well, I normally pay the difference between best available and a QF ticket but lately Jetstar have been half the price of everyone else on the FNQ sectors, at $200 a ticket the points are not worth it.

    VB are also suffering from a lack of freight business which Jetstar still get with AAE, contributing to the bottom line, although having a fleet of 737's is a big disadvantage for freight ops in the first place.

    Jetstar have their issues as well, after all Asia has not gone well, I suspect the real losers in all the changes are the QF staff, its clear the cost base is being driven down by the Jetstar expansion and many at QF will find themselves doing the same job with a lot less perks in the future.
     
  10. QF WP

    Moderator

    Jun 20, 2002
    14,240
    5,926
    Brisbane
    Flight Map:
    View my flight map
    Twitter:
    Facebook:
    Linkedin:
    Members might be interested in a Centre for Aviation article (I can't post link as only open to subscribers), edition #98, dated 29 Nov 05, outlines why DJ are confident that they can take on both Qantas and Jetstar and succeed. Those who want it can PM or email me and I'll email (it's a PDF format, 2.45MB).

    Also Bartholomew's article in The Age and SMH on 1 December 05 (can't find the link at the moment):

     
  11. jakeseven7

    jakeseven7 Active Member

    Sep 9, 2005
    560
    19
    None of this stuff was really new news to any of us - Virgins problems have been pretty well documented, and of course for PR they would never admit to this but I think it was more the whole low morale factor that suprised me, as someone else pointed out the whole Patrick/Toll thing is probably hurting them a bit.
     
  12. oz_mark

    oz_mark Enthusiast

    Jun 30, 2002
    16,875
    1,486
    Melbourne
    Flight Map:
    View my flight map
    I suspect that Virgin Blue is being somewhat distracted by the whole ownership thing. Watching the two airlines this year, I have the perception that it is Qantas that is the more nimble of the two airlines.

    I'd say what Virgin Blue need to do is gain some focus on what it is they are really trying to achieve - how do they grow the business and so on. There may be only the two airlines, but I think they both need to make sure that don't underestimate their competition.
     
  13. AndersB

    AndersB Newbie

    Sep 8, 2005
    9
    0
    Most flights domestically in Australia are short enough that any of the airlines' offerings could be endured. My buying decisions are heavily influenced by the features of the associated Frequent Flyer programs, hence my irritation with Qantas since May 05.

    However, with the Velocity Program's limited options for overseas award flight redemptions, DJ will still be my last choice.

    If DJ would be a Star Alliance member then I would direct 90% of my domestic travel to them.

    So, why can't they become part of Star Alliance? Are the minimum requirements for membership that difficult to achieve?
     
  14. QF WP

    Moderator

    Jun 20, 2002
    14,240
    5,926
    Brisbane
    Flight Map:
    View my flight map
    Twitter:
    Facebook:
    Linkedin:
    AndersB, I ws discussing that exact subject with a senior DJ manager on Friday. Can't post the details here, but PM me and I'll explain what I understand...
     
  15. Kiwi Flyer

    Kiwi Flyer Senior Member

    Sep 24, 2004
    5,453
    5
    If DJ joined *A then I'd use them more as well.

    There are 2 different categories of *A membership - full and regional IIRC.

    Full membership would require a lot of IT (in particular) investment to enable partner earning and burning, and apply the *A rules (eg recognising elites). I dont know how much if any these can be waived, but I'd expect alliance airlines have limited wiggle room as these are minimum benefits the alliance is "selling".

    There is also a large exit fee. IIRC when the QF-NZ tie-up was being considered a figure of $50m was bandied as *A exit fee. No idea how realistic this figure is but it certainly is significant enough that Air NZ publicly acknowledged exit fee to be an issue they had to take account of.

    Regional membership has lower requirements. Maybe DJ could join *A as a regional member?
     
  16. Mal

    Mal Enthusiast

    Dec 25, 2004
    12,215
    1,290
    London
    Flight Map:
    View my flight map
    I would like to see DJ join the * alliance.

    Then, they would be a real competition for Qantas in a lot more ways.

    As an airline, I think they have had a few stumbles recently. However I also see them as working out good ways to compete with Qantas in the Business market. I think their re-launch of lounges will be great when it happens. I also would like to see a premium product launched.
     
Loading...

Share This Page