Andrew, I usually stay clear of these discussions, however, when you suggest that economy travellers should get equal treatment regardless of status, I can't agree with you even though 90% of my travel is in Y. I believe you get what you pay for. If in F Class I expect to be treated and receive great service/food/wine etc like a king, and in J Class I expect comfort, good food and good wine, but in Y class I don't expect anything except a seat in a presurised metal tube because essentially that is what I have paid for with either money or points. The more you pay the more benefits you get, and although I don't have status I believe that exit rows should be allocated to Platinum/Gold status holders because they actually fly a lot with the airline and earn that privilege.