- Joined
- Nov 12, 2012
- Posts
- 32,749
- Qantas
- Platinum
- Virgin
- Gold
- Star Alliance
- Gold
Or Oman Air. As I noted here, their angus beef short rib that I had the flight before was falling-apart tender. A different cut - maybe there is a lesson there.
Agree. A few backs back the beef on the QF flight over was once again a disaster to the point I had one bite and gave up as the knife couldn’t even cut it. Staff were actually embarrassed about it.When they let a contract paying peanuts for the beef - they get what they pay for. They could buy it at Aldi and do better ! It cannot be a coincidence that QF beef is like shoe leather, when other airlines can do it much better. The answer is choose an airline that does not treat the pax as only a necessary evil, that their product reflects. CX beef is always good in my experience.
I feel the need to point out it isn't always boot leather. A reminder of my steak on QF37 in March. I was told they are loaded blue, what happens beyond that is up to the designated "cook" on board. This was melt in your mouth tender.When they let a contract paying peanuts for the beef - they get what they pay for. They could buy it at Aldi and do better ! It cannot be a coincidence that QF beef is like shoe leather, when other airlines can do it much better. The answer is choose an airline that does not treat the pax as only a necessary evil, that their product reflects. CX beef is always good in my experience.
Today's steak on QF 37. In no way overcooked. Very good actually. Sorry it's half eaten...View attachment 500765
I think you "hit the nail on the head"what happens beyond that is up to the designated "cook" on board.
They are unfortunately trained to be part of the “if it’s mooin’, I ain’t chewin’” group.I feel the need to point out it isn't always boot leather. A reminder of my steak on QF37 in March. I was told they are loaded blue, what happens beyond that is up to the designated "cook" on board. This was melt in your mouth tender.
That steak certainly fits Pulp Fiction's description of "burnt to a crisp"Beef fillet
It was the absolutely toughest bit of meat I’ve had in a long long time.
View attachment 512806
Always! That's why they are "safe". Short ribs and beef cheeks perfectly fit this kind of bill. It's a great alternative even for home cooks who don't want to gamble getting it wrong on steak (anywhere between purchasing it, storing it, preparing it for cook, cooking it and serving it). Even something like beef blade in a Boeuf Bourguignon would work very well.Slow cooked cuts seem a far safer prospect!
Always! That's why they are "safe". Short ribs and beef cheeks perfectly fit this kind of bill. It's a great alternative even for home cooks who don't want to gamble getting it wrong on steak (anywhere between purchasing it, storing it, preparing it for cook, cooking it and serving it). Even something like beef blade in a Boeuf Bourguignon would work very well.
Serving a beef filet is one of the biggest risks on board an aircraft. You're already dealing with non-ideal galley setups and then you want to prepare and serve one of the most difficult cuts of beef (without asking for preference of the customer, I might add). All respect for the crew, because they do the best that they can, but they're also not chefs. Even the ones who know good eating are relying highly on prep notes. I can see why they will probably err on the side of overcooked rather than undercooked. In a restaurant, undercooking something will probably result in a comped meal. On board, that flight attendant will probably have their legs broken at a minimum.
Sometimes the meat can come out a bit tough, but surprisingly well seasoned, and that can be tolerable. Same thing with well done beef - it can be tender enough and even juicy... but just mentioning "well done beef" to some people will be enough for them to lose all respect in you.
I honestly do not know how carriers and suppliers all around the world offer beef (roast beef, beef filet etc.) as a course and somehow prepare it for galley prep in a way that will be palatable on board. It is incredibly risky.
QF J aren't alone in this. I had a beef filet on EK F one time - sure, it was well done, but the texture was tough yet like wet sawdust - absolute failure (compounded by the rather limp sides). Who knows - another day I could have ordered the same thing and it comes out very nice.
The weird thing is that beef filet always makes it on the menu in QF J. Sure, they probably have a standing agreement with Barrington, but if the beef was such a failure every single time, you'd be a fool to keep offering it, or at least not without reviewing the way it is prepared and served. Either that or we are the only people who are getting and complaining about hockey pucks (i.e. everyone else seems to either get a good one or are content to eat a hockey puck).
We never seemed to have much of a problem serving steaks - even in economy back in the 70s and 80s! - when meals were pre-plated and the steaks sat in some sort of sauce. JAL and ANA still serve great steaks… but for short hops ex Japan they’re reheated together with the rest of the dish. I had a great steak on Lufthansa last year in business.Always! That's why they are "safe". Short ribs and beef cheeks perfectly fit this kind of bill. It's a great alternative even for home cooks who don't want to gamble getting it wrong on steak (anywhere between purchasing it, storing it, preparing it for cook, cooking it and serving it). Even something like beef blade in a Boeuf Bourguignon would work very well.
Serving a beef filet is one of the biggest risks on board an aircraft. You're already dealing with non-ideal galley setups and then you want to prepare and serve one of the most difficult cuts of beef (without asking for preference of the customer, I might add). All respect for the crew, because they do the best that they can, but they're also not chefs. Even the ones who know good eating are relying highly on prep notes. I can see why they will probably err on the side of overcooked rather than undercooked. In a restaurant, undercooking something will probably result in a comped meal. On board, that flight attendant will probably have their legs broken at a minimum.
Sometimes the meat can come out a bit tough, but surprisingly well seasoned, and that can be tolerable. Same thing with well done beef - it can be tender enough and even juicy... but just mentioning "well done beef" to some people will be enough for them to lose all respect in you.
I honestly do not know how carriers and suppliers all around the world offer beef (roast beef, beef filet etc.) as a course and somehow prepare it for galley prep in a way that will be palatable on board. It is incredibly risky.
QF J aren't alone in this. I had a beef filet on EK F one time - sure, it was well done, but the texture was tough yet like wet sawdust - absolute failure (compounded by the rather limp sides). Who knows - another day I could have ordered the same thing and it comes out very nice.
The weird thing is that beef filet always makes it on the menu in QF J. Sure, they probably have a standing agreement with Barrington, but if the beef was such a failure every single time, you'd be a fool to keep offering it, or at least not without reviewing the way it is prepared and served. Either that or we are the only people who are getting and complaining about hockey pucks (i.e. everyone else seems to either get a good one or are content to eat a hockey puck).
AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements
Always! That's why they are "safe". Short ribs and beef cheeks perfectly fit this kind of bill. It's a great alternative even for home cooks who don't want to gamble getting it wrong on steak (anywhere between purchasing it, storing it, preparing it for cook, cooking it and serving it). Even something like beef blade in a Boeuf Bourguignon would work very well.
Serving a beef filet is one of the biggest risks on board an aircraft. You're already dealing with non-ideal galley setups and then you want to prepare and serve one of the most difficult cuts of beef (without asking for preference of the customer, I might add). All respect for the crew, because they do the best that they can, but they're also not chefs. Even the ones who know good eating are relying highly on prep notes. I can see why they will probably err on the side of overcooked rather than undercooked. In a restaurant, undercooking something will probably result in a comped meal. On board, that flight attendant will probably have their legs broken at a minimum.
Sometimes the meat can come out a bit tough, but surprisingly well seasoned, and that can be tolerable. Same thing with well done beef - it can be tender enough and even juicy... but just mentioning "well done beef" to some people will be enough for them to lose all respect in you.
I honestly do not know how carriers and suppliers all around the world offer beef (roast beef, beef filet etc.) as a course and somehow prepare it for galley prep in a way that will be palatable on board. It is incredibly risky.
QF J aren't alone in this. I had a beef filet on EK F one time - sure, it was well done, but the texture was tough yet like wet sawdust - absolute failure (compounded by the rather limp sides). Who knows - another day I could have ordered the same thing and it comes out very nice.
The weird thing is that beef filet always makes it on the menu in QF J. Sure, they probably have a standing agreement with Barrington, but if the beef was such a failure every single time, you'd be a fool to keep offering it, or at least not without reviewing the way it is prepared and served. Either that or we are the only people who are getting and complaining about hockey pucks (i.e. everyone else seems to either get a good one or are content to eat a hockey puck).
