I just completed a 19-sector, 45k mile DONE5 over the last fortnight during which I sampled 6 different one world carriers, of which all but AA included long-haul. Some of my experiences surprised me and notwithstanding the fact that a single flight isn't always a true indicator of a carrier's quality, I thought I'd put in my findings for your interest and comments:
Best Service - CX.
For all-round quality it's hard to go past them
Best Meal - BA
Would you believe it? The Vegetarian Biryani (LHR-BOM) was delicious.
Best Wine - LA
Terrific Chilean wine, especially the Tannat Red (although Iberia's '96 Rioja ran a close second)
Best Seat - IB
A real surprise but a great seat setup in their new Business Plus
Best Lounge - CX Wing (HKG)
It really sets the standard
Best Airport - Madrid T4
New One World terminal is very well designed
Best (only) Handling of pax issues - QF
Painful people arguing over seats were handled with a combination of tact and firmness
Best Feeling - QF
Getting on that last flight home.....
Honourable Mention - AA
They were bearable
Overall Winner - CX
They were top 3 in most categories
Best Service - CX.
For all-round quality it's hard to go past them
Best Meal - BA
Would you believe it? The Vegetarian Biryani (LHR-BOM) was delicious.
Best Wine - LA
Terrific Chilean wine, especially the Tannat Red (although Iberia's '96 Rioja ran a close second)
Best Seat - IB
A real surprise but a great seat setup in their new Business Plus
Best Lounge - CX Wing (HKG)
It really sets the standard
Best Airport - Madrid T4
New One World terminal is very well designed
Best (only) Handling of pax issues - QF
Painful people arguing over seats were handled with a combination of tact and firmness
Best Feeling - QF
Getting on that last flight home.....
Honourable Mention - AA
They were bearable
Overall Winner - CX
They were top 3 in most categories