Business or hopefully First Class to SIN - help me pick a flight?

Status
Not open for further replies.
The BA flight does have F and it's a nice time of day to enjoy it. No chauffeur or anything like that, though.

If you book BNE-MEL-SIN on the same EK ticket, you'll get the chauffeur is BNE and then again in SIN.

EK and QF lounge in MEL.
 
Sponsored Post

Struggling to use your Frequent Flyer Points?

Frequent Flyer Concierge takes the hard work out of finding award availability and redeeming your frequent flyer or credit card points for flights.

Using their expert knowledge and specialised tools, the Frequent Flyer Concierge team at Frequent Flyer Concierge will help you book a great trip that maximises the value for your points.

aside: I have recently flown SQ F and Suites between east coast (MEL/SYD) and SIN and those were excellent flights

Yep, I have approx enough Velocity points to switch to KF and redeem SIN-LHR in F later on in the trip... :) I'm all about keeping my options open... :)
 
Another problem with BA is that the BNE-SYD leg will cost you extra.
 
Another problem with BA is that the BNE-SYD leg will cost you extra.
Oh would it? Cheeky monkeys! Oh well I have free flights with my Amex card so I could have always sorted something there if need be. Thanks for the tip though I wasn't aware of that.

About the only thing BA F has going for it is their High Tea menu looks yummy... and I'm not picking my airline for an amazing first-time experience like this, based on a couple of sandwiches and a cup of tea :) LOL
 
Another great luxury experience would be JL in F to NRT (they've recently uploaded F beyond late March, so availability is awesome), and then NH F to SIN using 50,000 LifeMiles. But that's obviously complicating things :)
 
Oh would it? Cheeky monkeys! Oh well I have free flights with my Amex card so I could have always sorted something there if need be. Thanks for the tip though I wasn't aware of that.

About the only thing BA F has going for it is their High Tea menu looks yummy... and I'm not picking my airline for an amazing first-time experience like this, based on a couple of sandwiches and a cup of tea :) LOL
Nothing special. :) BA F is a peg down with food and amenities and while I have had the afternoon tea a few times and it is OK, it really isn't an attraction. Long haul I always find their FAs in F good - J is a lot more patchy. Generally I would agree with EK on the A380 as the best choice.
 
If the booking is an award flight I am sure you do not get the Chauffeur drive when booked as an EK or QF flight number with Qantas Points, I do think if booked as an EK flight with EK points you may get the Chauffeur drive BUT not sure so worth double checking.


  • Chauffeur-drive service is not available on reward tickets booked via Emirates Skywards airline partners for travel on Emirates (with the exception of Qantas).
 
If the booking is an award flight I am sure you do not get the Chauffeur drive when booked as an EK or QF flight number with Qantas Points, I do think if booked as an EK flight with EK points you may get the Chauffeur drive BUT not sure so worth double checking.


  • Chauffeur-drive service is not available on reward tickets booked via Emirates Skywards airline partners for travel on Emirates (with the exception of Qantas).

But doesn't the line (with the exception of Qantas) that QF reward pax are different? Hmmmmmm.
Oh well, doesn't matter either way, what's a taxi fare in the grand scheme of things!
 
But doesn't the line (with the exception of Qantas) that QF reward pax are different? Hmmmmmm.
Oh well, doesn't matter either way, what's a taxi fare in the grand scheme of things!

Hence my statement about double checking would hate for any disapointment.
 
If the booking is an award flight I am sure you do not get the Chauffeur drive when booked as an EK or QF flight number with Qantas Points

Had it for an EK flight (SIN-BNE-CBR) booked using QF points as recently as last week.
 
That is good news, was that to ASIA or Europe. I know one definitely does not get it across the ditch. :D even in Paid F

mine was LHR, but it does work for SIN/KUL/BKK etc but yes, they nuked trans-tasman years ago. I did have it once in 2011 and it was very nice :)
 
For SIN-BNE-MEL with an overnight stay, I actually had four rides including to and from my Brisbane hotel.
 
If you have enough points, I would take the BA one as it leaves you time for lunch in the F QF lounge in SYD.
OR if you like an early dinner, the MEL F EK lounge one could be good too, dinner for the 7pm flight.
Between the 2, I would do the SYD one,
point 1.you get to eat lunch in the F lounge, or J lounge.
point 2.you leave SYD in time to get see the dusk on a plane, call me shallow.
point 3.you get to SIN at 9.30pm, still time to go walkabout.
point 4.you get dinner on the BA flight, full worth of the points value.
 
Scubabe, where are you starting this odyssey from?
Some airports are easier to transit, MEL eg, has T1 and T2 next door, SYD is a pain, so is BNE.
I feel the QF SYD F lounge is the one to go for, even if BA F service is not that good, but that F lounge is the creme de la creme, imagine, lunch time, I am drooling here.
I have done the QF MEL F lounge, and while some love it, I find the dream of the QF SYD F lounge the icing in the cake.
If you want to try something though, and earn some more QF points, you could try a J flight from Aust to NZ for a long weekend, they do the 380s as well across.
The 380 is a great bird to fly, esp the camera, those are the best things.
Granted that the 380 does vibrate and shudder on take off, but after take off, wow... to sum up, do the NZ trip at the least first to get a feel for the 380.
You can book the flight on the QF website as I did.
 
Scubabe, where are you starting this odyssey from?
Starting in BNE but happy to reposition anywhere on the East Coast :)

Thanks for the tips about the F lounge in SYD, definitely something to keep in mind... but I do think that the EK First is probably the preferable hard product over BA

The 380 is a great bird to fly, esp the camera, those are the best things.
I agree! When I moved to Australia 4 years ago I came in an A380 it was awesome :)
 
Ah, so you have flown the 380.
Seeing you want to get to SIN, the easiest one, with a dom connection from BNE, would be MEL airport. 2nd choice after MEL would be SYD, where QF buses get a dedicated road to use, between T3 and T1.
Getting an upgrade with points on a QF dom flight, you can get confirmation straight away.
But the goss on here for int flights is that it all (success) depends on your status, so apart from earning points from credit card spends, maybe you could also between now and the big trip do some QF flights around the country, to give yourself more chances of getting the J or F seats.
I am SG, but have not used a points upgrade int basis.
Not sure of my success if I did do it though.
I have noticed one very sneaky thing that QF does, is that it gives a very narrow time frame for dom to int transfers at SYD for those who don't live in SYD, for timings to use the J or F lounges. 1.5 to 2 hours after dom flight arrival, rush from T3 to T1 can take half an hour depending on the QF bus and its drivers, getting pass immi can also take time, 15 mins, theres 45 mins gone, 15 mins for the walk from SYD immi to the lounge and then 15 mins walk from lounge to gate...
Best of luck anyways.
 
The Frequent Flyer Concierge team takes the hard work out of finding reward seat availability. Using their expert knowledge and specialised tools, they'll help you book a great trip that maximises the value for your points.

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements

Ah, so you have flown the 380.
Seeing you want to get to SIN, the easiest one, with a dom connection from BNE, would be MEL airport. 2nd choice after MEL would be SYD, where QF buses get a dedicated road to use, between T3 and T1.
Getting an upgrade with points on a QF dom flight, you can get confirmation straight away.
But the goss on here for int flights is that it all (success) depends on your status, so apart from earning points from credit card spends, maybe you could also between now and the big trip do some QF flights around the country, to give yourself more chances of getting the J or F seats.
I am SG, but have not used a points upgrade int basis.
Not sure of my success if I did do it though.
I have noticed one very sneaky thing that QF does, is that it gives a very narrow time frame for dom to int transfers at SYD for those who don't live in SYD, for timings to use the J or F lounges. 1.5 to 2 hours after dom flight arrival, rush from T3 to T1 can take half an hour depending on the QF bus and its drivers, getting pass immi can also take time, 15 mins, theres 45 mins gone, 15 mins for the walk from SYD immi to the lounge and then 15 mins walk from lounge to gate...
Best of luck anyways.

Oh for the love of....

Seriously Poochie, you go off on so many unrelated tangents and assumptions and comments that it's hard to keep track of whatever point you're trying to make.

As I understand it, the OP is looking at points redemptions in J or F ex BNE to go to SIN. It's possible one can get an "F" award BNE-SYD-SIN or BNE-MEL-SIN with the domestic sectors "thrown in" in J. However the OP may wish to arrange their own transport to a gateway depending on the end result.

Not everyone is as totally obsessed with the FLounge as you are, and now you've finally been to the MEL one I thought your zeal may have subsided a tad since you seem disappointed. I would say some people prefer the MEL lounge because, while it is smaller, the service can be better (my last few times in SYD the service has been poor and the place crowded but everyone's experiences vary).

If the OP can fly post March when it seems EK405 MEL-SIN will be on the 380, then I think that gives the best of all worlds, assuming F availability is there (that's a whole other ssue, but at least the 380 has more F seats).

Finally re connections - your comment is, IMHO, rubbish. There are many connections that can be made over hours. The reason QF offers, by default, the shorter transits that are close to MCT are for the convenience of passengers to have the last amount of time waiting between flights - which most people without lounge access, or who simply just want to get to where they're going would prefer. However it is entirely possible to make longer connections for QF dom-international specially for afternoon and evening departures (obviously if one has a 19 or 10am departure out of SYD it's difficult to get a long connect if your first departure out of MEL or BNE can only get you there around 0730.

Last month I organised and flew a 3.5 hour transit in SYD between MEL-SYD and SYD-SFO - plenty of time for a leisurely lunch in the lounge, some relaxing time watching the ramp and then to go endure the fun at the gate.

Point is that suggesting QF providing short connections is "sneaky" is ridiculous. I can understand the more practical issue of a too short connection being difficult to make a flight, specially if your domestic connection is delayed, but most airlines around the world follow similar practices - it's just that the SYD dom->int has the extra hassle of having to clear immigration and security(again) in SYD which can add time and hassle on top of the bus, but it's far from "sneaky"

Back to the OP - if it was me and given all you've written I'd aim for BNE-MEL-SIN on the EK flight - even if you can only get a J award the product is going to be pretty good with the bar and stuff. F is much nicer specially on the longer runs, but may not be so easy to secure. If it were between BA and EK, which are the only real options for First, I'd go EK even with the later arrival in SIN. My 2 cents.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Enhance your AFF viewing experience!!

From just $6 we'll remove all advertisements so that you can enjoy a cleaner and uninterupted viewing experience.

And you'll be supporting us so that we can continue to provide this valuable resource :)


Sample AFF with no advertisements? More..

Recent Posts

Back
Top