AA's monumental stuff-up

Status
Not open for further replies.

wrldtrvllr

Member
Joined
Jan 4, 2008
Posts
188
After having some major flight dramas and associated baggage delays I'm considering requesting (demanding) some form of compensation from AA and would be interested in hearing your opinions and if you have encountered similar situations previously.

So I have a ticketed DCIR29SA with a LAX-HNL flight on AA297 for 16/6 @ 510pm and a seat assigned except when I go to check in @ the 1st class counter (with half a dozen passengers in front and only 1 desk open it took almost 1/2 hr to get served!) I'm told I can't get on the flight because it is full! what the!? it looks like they were way oversold and the first come first served rule applied...next best thing the lady could do is put me on standby for the next flight AA267 @ 820pm; I point out that i had a 1st class ticket, she says should have no problems getting such a seat; I point out that I had connecting flight HNL-ITO (on a separate reservation and different airline) that I will now miss, she says she can't (I read unwilling) do anything about it (I suspect she didn't like the look of me as a 1st class passenger since she pointed out that this is the 1st class check-in when I approached the counter); we to and fro a bit but she is insistent on being unable to do anything (really? LAN had no problems accommodating a missed connection with competitor airline due to their delayed flight, although begrudgingly after I filed a damaged baggage claim and missed the original arrangements made by LAN) so I accept the standby option, check my 2 bags for that flight and head up to the gate. Funny that I get the SSSS code on my ticket so get personal attention at the security screening...

Gate attendents are finalising who can get on their oversold AA297 flight; I check with them on 1st class and nope it's full. In the time between I make arrangements for accommodation in HNL expecting to be on the AA267 and have an enforced layover en-route to ITO.

Boarding time comes and goes for AA267 and even though I'm #1 on standby not only can I not get a seat in 1st but there is nothing available in coach - damn check-in lady was telling me lies! Supervisor is willing to help after hearing my story and closing the last flight to HNL for the day. I point out I am supposed to get to ITO; best he can do is get me in 1st, confirmed on AA161 LAX-OGG on AA the next afternoon (510pm 17/6) then connecting flights OGG-HNL and HNL-KOA on Go! (Mesa) Doesn't quite get me to where I needed to get to but at least it's the same island (though 3hrs away by car); Don't think I really have much choice so I accept (check-in lady is wrong again!) and he gives me accommodation voucher plus dinner and b/fast voucher. And of course my bags that were on the AA267 to HNL would be forwarded to KOA for me...

Get on flight AA161 fine but the lady I'm seated next to had missed a connection the previous evening and was put up in the same hotel and given dinner ($20), b/fast ($10) and lunch ($20) vouchers - huh?! I was only given $10 for dinner and a measly $5 for b/fast - discriminatory behaviour again - and I'm wondering if there is a sign on my forehead that reads "homeless bum - do not render much assistance". Fortunately I've kept all receipts and will "bill" them the difference...

Connecting flights go fine but when I get to KOA at 11pm to collect my fowarded bags (I had taken a call in LAX earlier in the day telling me my bags were going to be fowarded to KOA on an earlier flight for me to pick up from Go!) there's no one at Go! baggage to help, nor is there anyone at the carousel (though I was close to being the 1st one out there) so go looking for the AA desk - not staffed; the airport is pretty much shut with only security around and a few lingering airline staff - try United - no bags held for me; Hawaiian - nothing - and that's the wrap, everyone else has left the building. head back to the Go! carousel and no one is around so frustrated and exasperated I head to hotel expecting to call AA the next morning and have bags forwarded to my hotel....

Yeah right, wishful thinking... call their 1800 baggage number and they tell me the bags were forwarded to KOA for me to pick up; I explain my story and put in a request to have bags forwarded to my hotel in Kona; 2 days later and numerous calls to their 1800 number with still no status update beyond the bags were forwarded to KOA on Go! I tell them I need to move on form Kona and leave mobile for them to reach me once they locate the bags. More phone calls and an operator tells me I should have filed a claim with Go! since they were handling the bags to KOA and gives me a number to call - turns out to be their reservations number! Have to look up the number myself and I call Go! in KOA directly - get answered by United!? (who look to be handling Go!'s baggage services). The guy then bluntly (after he finds out that I "filed" a claim with AA) tells me he is holding no bags for me (lies!) and I need to contact AA. So the game of phone tennis goes on and it's back to AA. More days pass and still nothing beyond the bags have been fowarded to KOA on Go! on 17/6 (yes, but where are they now?!) and no closer to being reunited with bags and about to head back to HNL on 22/6 I tell them to forward the bags there for me to pick up - I tell the flight details (flying hawaiian airliners) and accommodation arrangements.

22/6 comes and I get to HNL around 930pm and check with the helpful hawaiian air baggage desk to see if they are holding any bags - none for me; get them to try Go! and AA (neither is there). Defeated once again I head to hotel to try call AA the next morning and have bags forwarded to hotel. 1800 number tells me I need to fax a baggage claim (since it is more than 5days); point out didn't I have one filed when I first called up? Nope need to fax one in - so it's off to the airport I go on 23/6. Lady at AA baggage counter tells me she's been in contact with Go! in KOA and they've located 1 bag which should be coming in later that afternoon - don't really know where the other bag is and neither does go! (they don't have a computerised system to keep track of their luggage apparently). We go take a walk to the Go! terminal but there is no one at their baggage counter so we go to their "back" entrance" to see if the other bag has arrived earlier - nope; check Hawaiian - nope.

evening 23/6 and the 1 bag is delivered to the hotel but still don't know where the other bag is... I was originally scheduled to fly HNL-NRT on 23/6 but travelling without my luggage didn't seem too desireable so I've had to defer my departure to 25/6 so hopefully they should be able to locate and get the other bag to me...

Having been without my bags for over a week I check with the AA baggage lady if there is any compensation available; she points out that I should have filed a baggage claim with Go! since they were handling the bags; I point out that that is really AA's own doing since they arranged the connections and baggage fowarding after stuffing up my flights. If they knew Go! was so unreliable they could have used the much more efficient Hawaiian airlines; she notes my extenuating circumstance and says I can go onto their website and write in to their customer service - I fully intend to do just that but how easy is it getting some compensation from AA? Is it like getting blood from a stone? I could easily bill them $500/day for the inconvenience in changing and rechanging my onward travel arrangement and time wasting they've caused. Plus the fact that with my Big Island stop (ITO) I was scheduled to do a bit of hiking (they have mountains here over 4000m) but with all my hiking gear with my luggage that wasn't really a viable option so a free round trip from Sydney should cover that? My only concern is that I don't have an "official" baggage claim document since I called it in over the phone and without it my "complaint" doesn't have as much weight plus travel insurance won't pay any claim. How can I "force" AA to give me an official baggage claim? Anyone been successful in "billing" an airline for similar scenarios?

Apologies for the long post (but you did enjoy reading about my misfortune right?) :confused:
 
OMG - what a horrible story!

My worst luggage experience was QF fault. Flying into LHR on QF and then out of LGW on BA to Venice.

I tried to explain in check in at Mel that bags should be tagged to LHR and we will collect. However, check in lady knew better and said no no no - they are to be tagged through. Gave up.

Sure enough arrived at LHR, asked BA baggage services - they said the bag will end up in a dead end! They said they were angry as QF did this all the time and it was "naughty and wrong".

Anyway, no bags so got bus to Gatwick. Flew to Venice. Filed missing baggage report there. Went out to the airport next day after arrival of next BA flight. Contacted baggage services and cases had turned up so we grabbed them. They had offered to bring them into venice but anyone that's been to venice will know you can't actually find anything there so thought it safer to grab the bags ourselves!

Didn't claim any compensation, travel insurance etc. Just laughed it off as one of those things.
 
Taking the separate parts

Since you had , as you said, a separate ticket to ITO, AA had no responsibility to get you there at all. It is a risk you take with separate tickets. It seems that a supervisor did attempt to get you close to your destination despite having no necessity to do so. You have no valid complaint there

Flights do get oversold and , if you checked in by the cutoff time , then you would have been eligable for IBD compensation. If by the time you got to the desk it was within 45 mins of departure ( which is iirc the baggage acceptance cutoff time ) then you were too late

The SSSS on the BP has nothing to do with the check in agent regardless of what is implied

If the check in person put you on standby for AA67, what exactly did she say that was untrue. Standby means standby and requires that there is availability for you to get onboard. If you were high on the list but did not clear then that is because the flight check in as full. If there had been seats at the time , then the agent would have checked you in there and then rather than make you stand by

Differening levels of compensation for delays do exist and could have easily been to do with that persons status with AA. You may have kept receipts but that does not mean that AA will necessaily be liable to reimburse

When the luggage failed to appear, you should have ( as the AA staff menber stated ) lodged a missing luggage claim with Go. Go would then liase accordingly

If the luggage is completely lost, then I believe that their liability is limited to $398 approx due to it being an international itinerary

Did you not have travel insurance? Most policies have a delayed luggage facility which would have covered you for a few hundred dollars to purchase essentials ( such a s hiking gear if your plan was to go hiking ).

Your suggestion that AA provide a r/t flight to Hawaii from Sydney is risible and has approximately a zero chance of success

It may have been an unfortunate situation, but overall with AA it does just come down to a denied boarding on an overnight flight and delayed luggage, both of which may be covered by insurance

Dave
 
Read our AFF credit card guides and start earning more points now.

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements

Dave Noble said:
... If the luggage is completely lost, then I believe that their liability is limited to $398 approx due to it being an international itinerary ...
All USA carriers are under the Montreal treaty irrespective of routing; max liability for lost luggage is 1000 XDRs (~USD1800)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Become an AFF member!

Join Australian Frequent Flyer (AFF) for free and unlock insider tips, exclusive deals, and global meetups with 65,000+ frequent flyers.

AFF members can also access our Frequent Flyer Training courses, and upgrade to Fast-track your way to expert traveller status and unlock even more exclusive discounts!

AFF forum abbreviations

Wondering about Y, J or any of the other abbreviations used on our forum?

Check out our guide to common AFF acronyms & abbreviations.
Back
Top