Does anyone ever pay QF domestic J prices out of their own pocket? I've always thought they put those prices there for the occasional person in the happy position where the company or the tax payer is picking up the tab.
Sad to say, yes "people" do pay Qantas's ridiculous world-record high prices for domestic biz class. And who are these unfortunate "people" - why, that's you and me paying through our taxes or our super funds for govt officials and corporate execs.
For those of us playing the status game (to make it worth it, i.e. get and be able to use it, and not from a cold start), some QF J fares, if bought in advance long enough, work out quite reasonably in terms of $ per SC. If you had to take that trip anyway, it isn't so ridiculous to pay QF J for it.
I had a trip to GLT once where the return sector had the cheapest available Y seat was a mere $100 less than the J price. That difference and the associated perks, albeit small ex-GLT, was worth $100 (but of course one could argue that the Y price was a rip off; needless to say it was a last minute trip).
Now anything between east coast and PER.... I have never been able to make sense of any price for J on that (except perhaps combined with an international sector).
Nope I think sinking every member with the same date is dumb.
I like the rolling anniversary of VA.
I don't mind QF system either.
I think it highly depends on where you started your loyalty journey. In LOTFAP (and Canada), so many programmes are based on the calendar year - that's just how it is. Many other places around the world it is based on a member-specific anniversary. Arguing which is better is more or less like arguing whether milk goes first or hot water goes first.
I got the VA system pretty quickly after it was released; many on AFF didn't, and me trying to explain it was met with even more confusion (and just a bit of derision).
I always think - their game, their rules, you don't need to play. But one advantage of VA rolling SCs is that if you fail to meet the retain target in time, it is still possible to obtain your former status again rather quickly, depending on the timing of your SCs.