The world's stingiest airport lounge?

Joined
Aug 21, 2011
Posts
15,068
Qantas
Platinum
Virgin
Platinum
SkyTeam
Elite Plus
Star Alliance
Gold
At what point can an airport lounge offer so few amenities that it's better just to wait in the terminal?

I was asking myself this last night while waiting for an Air Astana flight in the "Business Lounge" at ALA (Almaty, Kazakhstan). It's the only lounge at ALA and is basically just a glorified waiting room.

IMG_3285.jpeg

There are toilets and the seats are reasonably comfortable. Here endeth the amenities of this lounge. Well, except perhaps for the five clocks on the wall showing the time in different cities (Almaty, Istanbul, New York, etc.) - but none of these actually showed the correct time.

There is a bar serving food and drinks, but absolutely everything costs extra. There are laminated menus on all the tables with prices listed, and the prices are pretty expensive by local standards.

IMG_3286.jpeg
IMG_3287.jpeg


There's also a 10% service charge added to all orders, and a tip jar on the counter with a sign on it that looks like it says "tips payable" - but I'll give the benefit of the doubt and assume the second word is actually a Kazakh or Russian word that looks like "payable" in English.

Behind the bar, there is actually a small (but rather sad looking) buffet. However, you're only allowed to enter the buffet area if you're flying on Lufthansa, Qatar, Uzbekistan Airways, Flydubai, Asiana or Aeroflot. I was flying Air Astana in J (this is the main operator at the airport), and wasn't permitted to access the buffet.

For some reason, if you enter using Priority Pass, you do get a voucher for the airport café (located outside the lounge). I have Priority Pass so did this.

IMG_2595.jpeg

That's the only outside food or drink that you can bring into the lounge - there are signs on every table advising of this.

Those aren't the only signs around the lounge. There are "no sleeping" signs, as well as one that says "no wifi". That's right, a "business lounge" that doesn't provide wifi.

On the bar counter are two jars with small chocolates in them. These jars are covered by large signs saying "not for free".

To top off the experience, the man sitting at the table behind me was listening to loud music without headphones. The noise became so irritating in my sleep-deprived state that I left the lounge to get some peace and quiet in the main terminal.

It's a shame because Air Astana has its own lounge in Astana (its other hub) that was quite OK. And once on board, the Air Astana J service is great. But the lounge in Almaty needs a bit of work... hopefully the situation will improve when the new terminal opens.

Has anyone come across a worse airport lounge?
 
At what point can an airport lounge offer so few amenities that it's better just to wait in the terminal?

I was asking myself this last night while waiting for an Air Astana flight in the "Business Lounge" at ALA (Almaty, Kazakhstan). It's the only lounge at ALA and is basically just a glorified waiting room.

View attachment 337432

There are toilets and the seats are reasonably comfortable. Here endeth the amenities of this lounge. Well, except perhaps for the five clocks on the wall showing the time in different cities (Almaty, Istanbul, New York, etc.) - but none of these actually showed the correct time.

There is a bar serving food and drinks, but absolutely everything costs extra. There are laminated menus on all the tables with prices listed, and the prices are pretty expensive by local standards.

View attachment 337434
View attachment 337433


There's also a 10% service charge added to all orders, and a tip jar on the counter with a sign on it that looks like it says "tips payable" - but I'll give the benefit of the doubt and assume the second word is actually a Kazakh or Russian word that looks like "payable" in English.

Behind the bar, there is actually a small (but rather sad looking) buffet. However, you're only allowed to enter the buffet area if you're flying on Lufthansa, Qatar, Uzbekistan Airways, Flydubai, Asiana or Aeroflot. I was flying Air Astana in J (this is the main operator at the airport), and wasn't permitted to access the buffet.

For some reason, if you enter using Priority Pass, you do get a voucher for the airport café (located outside the lounge). I have Priority Pass so did this.

View attachment 337435

That's the only outside food or drink that you can bring into the lounge - there are signs on every table advising of this.

Those aren't the only signs around the lounge. There are "no sleeping" signs, as well as one that says "no wifi". That's right, a "business lounge" that doesn't provide wifi.

On the bar counter are two jars with small chocolates in them. These jars are covered by large signs saying "not for free".

To top off the experience, the man sitting at the table behind me was listening to loud music without headphones. The noise became so irritating in my sleep-deprived state that I left the lounge to get some peace and quiet in the main terminal.

It's a shame because Air Astana has its own lounge in Astana (its other hub) that was quite OK. And once on board, the Air Astana J service is great. But the lounge in Almaty needs a bit of work... hopefully the situation will improve when the new terminal opens.

Has anyone come across a worse airport lounge?
Hahaha i remember this from 2019 when we flew J with Asiana. However I don’t remember being allowed to enter buffet area
 
If it had walls and a door, that would be better than the former AirBerlin lounges aka “exclusive waiting areas” that were basically roped off waiting areas with self serve water.
 
If it had walls and a door, that would be better than the former AirBerlin lounges aka “exclusive waiting areas” that were basically roped off waiting areas with self serve water.

TXL did come to mind while I was sitting in that lounge last night 😂

At least Airberlin didn't have the gall to call its exclusive waiting areas "lounges" :)
 
How about NTL lounge when QF Link used to have such a thing? Early 2000’s maybe? 6m x 5m?

It had a push button lock on the door and the access code was given to you by the check in staff. Inside was maybe 8 chairs and all I recall was little packets of two Arnotts biscuits, sort of like you get at some motels. Might have been some Blend43 sachets and tea bags, but I don’t recall a zipboil or how you got the hot water to make a cuppa so maybe there were no drinks.

I’d also offer the ‘room’ that UL called its lounge for flights from GAN in the Maldives. Pale yellow walls, some beige upholstered chairs and a bar. Except the bar was just a piece of furniture with some room temp water bottles sitting on top. That’s it.
 
I particularly liked the line at the bottom of both menus - in case of poor-service ......... write to the number +7.....

I do hope you wrote to that telephone number. o_O
 
Haha when I read the post title the ALA lounge was the exact lounge that came to mind. Visited it in 2018 flying on Asiana - there was a sign at the buffet saying we weren't allowed access but nobody was policing it. I think we smuggled in booze from outside. Terrible lounge.
 
The HA lounge at Kona is pretty bad, it seats about 10 people and serves coffee/soft drink and little bags of pretzel mix. If you need the loo you need to leave the lounge. But at least it has aircon.
 
Like @randompunter, I saw the thread title and immediately thought of that lounge at Alma Ata - with signs everywhere telling you that you can't have anything.

When I went to the Al Mourjan lounge in Doha last year it was something similar, except instead of paying with cash, you had to pay with time. There were not enough seats for everyone so people were sitting on the floor or on the edge of a large indoor pond thing. There were long queues for food, drink, showers etc. that the attendants told you were measured in hours, not minutes. The lounge itself had nothing to look at and had significant noise pollution from a brass band playing outside. I did go to the new Garden lounge in Doha in May and it was much better.

The old EgyptAir lounge at Cairo was bad but in a different way. You could get free soft drinks and pre-wrapped slices of cake, but the lounge itself were sofas that looked soft but were rock hard, on a roped off balcony half way up a stairwell overlooking the main concourse.
 
How about NTL lounge when QF Link used to have such a thing? Early 2000’s maybe? 6m x 5m?

It had a push button lock on the door and the access code was given to you by the check in staff. Inside was maybe 8 chairs and all I recall was little packets of two Arnotts biscuits, sort of like you get at some motels. Might have been some Blend43 sachets and tea bags, but I don’t recall a zipboil or how you got the hot water to make a cuppa so maybe there were no drinks.

Gosh, reminds me of the room at KTA! I was going to bring it up until I read Matt's experience of everything costing extra. At least in KTA there was a fridge!
 
The Frequent Flyer Concierge team takes the hard work out of finding reward seat availability. Using their expert knowledge and specialised tools, they'll help you book a great trip that maximises the value for your points.

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements

I can't believe HBA is worse than Alma Ata. I have just found my photo of the notice greeting us on the bar of the lounge. At least they let you into the lounge there - there was apparently a lounge in Dushanbe that nobody is allowed in.
At least they had a boarding call service. If they even had the 'paging Mr...', that'd be almost generous... 🤭
 

Enhance your AFF viewing experience!!

From just $6 we'll remove all advertisements so that you can enjoy a cleaner and uninterupted viewing experience.

And you'll be supporting us so that we can continue to provide this valuable resource :)


Sample AFF with no advertisements? More..
Back
Top