i'm not a fan of these as some may know... But everyone has to remember the taster's weren't getting used as a taster they were a new fare class to fly PE/Business at a very cheap option.
As i have mentioned before i only fly PE/J class with VA, and the problem with these represents a big issue.
If you upgrade people on flights, when i show up an hour earlier in the airport and want to move to an earlier flight i can't as they've allowed others to move to earlier flights, and then pay the upgrade option. The only way to get around this is to only allow say 2 fares on board to be upgrades. That way ensuring your full paying business/PE passengers can get the benefits.
One of the big benefits of the fare class for me, is moving to earlier flights. I've had problems in the past, where i've not been able to take an earlier flight, not because there wasn't availability, but because people had been on cheap upgrades, which in turn meant i lost the benefit of it. (whilst there were seats still in y and y+)... This has happened many many times to me.. VA have always tried to sort something out...
I think the program they've got in place now with the 4 comp's for Plat, and Paid (points) upgrades for everyone else is a best option fit. I noticed that there are 4 seats allocated to each aircraft load (in H class) which is the points/rewards redemption seating class for PE/J..
I know alot will take the perception that we want the upgrades, as a PE/J flyer all the time, you need to understand there is two sides to the story, and i'd like to be able to get on an earlier flight if possible. There are other positives and negatives out of this upgrades, which i don't think need to be discussed. But i do think VA has it right.. And has tried to find the middle ground on this..
Thought from reading this forum, it still sounds like getting a free upgrade into PE/J at the airport is still very possible, which rumor's where that had stopped.