Personally, I don't find this news "earth shattering". But to be fair, I see benefit for many FFers.
My thoughts? If I'm interested, it'd be platinum as the free rtn flight pays the card fee.
Well firstly, the negatives.........
The insurance component to me is worthless. A must for a travel insurance policy for me, is a hire car excess component and the Amex doesn't do that, so another policy is required regardless (or pay the $35 per day or so excess reduction fees).
Amex is not really a surprise. They'll hop into bed with anyone to make them a little more palatable but reality to me is that they would have to rank close to the most despised CC crowds around, as assessed by the consumers and the retailers. I experienced them once.......and they'll have to offer something pretty good to make that road worth traveling again :evil:. Plus many retailers won't accept Amex
.
2,4,1 J fares has been discussed already at length, and for me, if I were to buy J fares, I'd be shopping around hard and expect points and SCs.
2 passes to the lounge?? I already have unlimited.
Now, on the plus side........
30 000 points is a sweetner and worth real money (although is short lived).
3 points with Virgin spend and 1.5 for others is better than I get (much better) than with my Westpac Altitude Gold.
And last but not least.....the freebie return Saver fare between select cities which is also worth real money. Say about $378 (BNE-ADL-BNE) which is more than the annual card fee.
So the upshot for me is a very definite, maybe! I've previously vowed and declared NEVER to give another cent to Amex and that may well be the case now, but there is benefit there too.
I'll sleep on it (many nights over I'd say).