JAL/United/ANA & American/Qatar Business Jakarta to New York from $2,504 USD

Gold Member

Established Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2008
Posts
1,962

$3,750 AUD. Includes a free stopover in Japan and up to 12 months stopover in the US (great for nested itineraries).

WhereToCredit is reporting 0 SC earn on QF. I can’t be bothered trying to dissect QF‘s unfair and complicated earn tables, but is related to not recognising “X” as a legitimate business earning bucket?

EDIT: I’m also seeing very similar pricing for the same routing on United and ANA (via Japan), as well as Qatar and American (via Doha). Updated title to reflect.
 
Last edited:

$3,750 AUD. Includes a free stopover in Japan and up to 12 months stopover in the US (great for nested itineraries).

WhereToCredit is reporting 0 SC earn on QF. I can’t be bothered trying to dissect QF‘s unfair and complicated earn tables, but is related to not recognising “X” as a legitimate business earning bucket?
X earns as Business Class SC to QF.
 
The Frequent Flyer Concierge team takes the hard work out of finding reward seat availability. Using their expert knowledge and specialised tools, they'll help you book a great trip that maximises the value for your points.

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements


$3,750 AUD. Includes a free stopover in Japan and up to 12 months stopover in the US (great for nested itineraries).

WhereToCredit is reporting 0 SC earn on QF. I can’t be bothered trying to dissect QF‘s unfair and complicated earn tables, but is related to not recognising “X” as a legitimate business earning bucket?
“WhereToCredit” defaults to “Zone based” for QF - even they can’t manage to calculate post ‘Simpler & Fairer’ TM. In turn, LL always stuffs up and just defaults to zero…

The QF calc will show the correct earn. For this one: (120 + 160) x 2. Nice indeed.

I recently booked CX J ex CGK and only get 80 SCs CGK-HKG 😔
 
“WhereToCredit” defaults to “Zone based” for QF - even they can’t manage to calculate post ‘Simpler & Fairer’ TM. In turn, LL always stuffs up and just defaults to zero…

The QF calc will show the correct earn. For this one: (120 + 160) x 2. Nice indeed.

I recently booked CX J ex CGK and only get 80 SCs CGK-HKG 😔
In fairness to WTC, their earn tables work for the vast majority of airlines using miles flown (with cabin multipliers) as the basis for status AND miles earning. QF and some other airlines complicate matters by employing separate calculations for miles and status earned. It’s no surprise then that WTC reports 0 earn - ‘Simpler & Fairer’ TM indeed.
 
I need to go to SFO-LAS-LAX-NYC and has been looking for some cheap J fares. Apart from starting from Jakarta, I found similar (slightly more expenisve) fares from Hanoi to SFO. The fare on aa is cheaper than Kayak or Skyscanner which is a bit strange.

I may end up doing HAN-NRT-SFO then JFK-NRT-HAN for A$4.7k.
 
I need to go to SFO-LAS-LAX-NYC and has been looking for some cheap J fares. Apart from starting from Jakarta, I found similar (slightly more expenisve) fares from Hanoi to SFO. The fare on aa is cheaper than Kayak or Skyscanner which is a bit strange.

I may end up doing HAN-NRT-SFO then JFK-NRT-HAN for A$4.7k.
I did the trip in Mar /Apr and got 480 SC. Booked with AA but JAL metal. A$4.7k which is great value. Looking at another trip in late May and pricing is the same.
 

Enhance your AFF viewing experience!!

From just $6 we'll remove all advertisements so that you can enjoy a cleaner and uninterupted viewing experience.

And you'll be supporting us so that we can continue to provide this valuable resource :)


Sample AFF with no advertisements? More..
Back
Top