Hi everyone
I have just completed a trip MEL- HKG - LHR then MUC-SIN-MEL. Last year I also flew J for the first time and flew MEL-NRT - MEL.
I have now flown on JAL, Qantas, British Airways, Singapore Airlines in that order in J.
My comments on each business class and ratings are as follows:
JAL
Food: Very good, choice of Japanese or Western and very stylish presentation
Seating: Very comfy seating module
Service: Very good, polite staff, attentive although a little formal
Overall rating: 8/10
Qantas:
Food: Very good
Seating: Again, very comfy seating module
Service: Great Australian staff, fun to fly with, like a pyjama party in the sky
Overall rating: 8/10
British Airways
Food: Very good
Seating: Ummm, flying backwards? Still, seat was acceptable although outdated
Service: Great French and British older staff, was well looked after.
Overall rating: 7/10
Singapore Airways
Food: Not so great. Tasty but meat was chewy
Seating: Seat was hard and did not provide a fully reclinable bed. Not great.
Service: Far and away the best service from a young and attentive crew. SIN deserves its reputation for service excellence.
Overall rating: 6/10 (unfortunate due to outdated equipment and average food).
Still all the above are way better than flying Y so I'm not complaining.
cheers Peter
I have just completed a trip MEL- HKG - LHR then MUC-SIN-MEL. Last year I also flew J for the first time and flew MEL-NRT - MEL.
I have now flown on JAL, Qantas, British Airways, Singapore Airlines in that order in J.
My comments on each business class and ratings are as follows:
JAL
Food: Very good, choice of Japanese or Western and very stylish presentation
Seating: Very comfy seating module
Service: Very good, polite staff, attentive although a little formal
Overall rating: 8/10
Qantas:
Food: Very good
Seating: Again, very comfy seating module
Service: Great Australian staff, fun to fly with, like a pyjama party in the sky
Overall rating: 8/10
British Airways
Food: Very good
Seating: Ummm, flying backwards? Still, seat was acceptable although outdated
Service: Great French and British older staff, was well looked after.
Overall rating: 7/10
Singapore Airways
Food: Not so great. Tasty but meat was chewy
Seating: Seat was hard and did not provide a fully reclinable bed. Not great.
Service: Far and away the best service from a young and attentive crew. SIN deserves its reputation for service excellence.
Overall rating: 6/10 (unfortunate due to outdated equipment and average food).
Still all the above are way better than flying Y so I'm not complaining.
cheers Peter