Business Class for AKL-MEL on 8 Jan

[Diving Falcon]

I need to fly AKL-MEL on 8 Jan 2010, and am looking for advice from the experts on AFF on the best/cheapest way to fly in business class, given the high season.

I have already booked a flight QF26 in fully flexible economy for $500, but I would like to fly in business if possible.

I have seen two options - an EK business fare for about $520 on EK407, or I can request an upgrade for 16K QF points.

This will be the first time I will fly business class, so I am looking for a good experience, despite the relatively short flight. Looking particularly for a good meal (especially as I am vegetarian) and decent IFE.

Questions:
1. What is the chance I will get upgraded for 16K points on QF26?

2. Am I better off getting a refund on my QF economy fare and buying the EK business fare?

3. Are there any other alternatives to fly business AKL-MEL on 8/1 for no more than $600?

(FYI I am a Qantas Club member and am QF Silver, but no other status)

Thanks so much for your help! Happy to provide any more info if needed.

 

[tuapekastar]

You can purchase QF J for ~AUD595 (plus CC fee) if you logon to QF as an NZer. No idea what your upgrade chances are, nor have I flown EK. But EK at AUD520 sounds a pretty decent option if you wish to fly J and have no need to credit to QFF.

On QF26 you should get a 738 with seatback IFE (quite good IMHO). I suspect EK would be better, though that's only an assumption. Food/drinks are fine IMO on QF (though I'm not a veg, so have taken no particular notice of that option).