Agoda - Never Again!

bcworld

Established Member
Joined
May 26, 2010
Posts
3,908
Qantas
Bronze
Virgin
Platinum
Just wanted to share some details of a recent experience I had with Agoda...a company I have been booking with since at least 2009, if not before.

I booked 5 nights at beach resort in Seminyak, Bali. The room type was a 190sqm private pool villa, in a resort, and the room rate close to A$500p/n. I have stayed at this resort before, and certainly while I thought this was a good deal...it is not out of the range for similar properties in the same area.

36 hours before departure, call from Agoda. There's been an error. You can have absolutely the lowest room category in the hotel, a twin room, located in the satellite building a few minutes walk down the street. No you can't have any refund but you can have USD150 compensation total! The room they are offering me is currently for sale on their website at A$370 per night (with some advance booking, typically more like A$250)...but they can't understand why their $30 per night compensation offer doesn't sit well with me. I tell them no, and am prepared to be reasonable. I ask them to instead get me the best room category available...there are no villas left, but the suite category is available last minute at A$600pn. After a few minutes they revert with a "no" and upping their compensation offer to USD250. Then they stop responding to any emails or chat messages...closing any chats off with, "your case has been closed" type messages.

In desperation I call back some random number in Malaysia that called me previously and do manage to speak to customer service. The long and the short is that I then spend the next 90 minutes arguing with them that, the fact that my room rate was non-refundable has no bearing here as they are the ones that downgraded me from close to the highest room category to the absolute lowest...they insist over and over its non-refundable.

Ultimately I get to a very aggressive manager who again argues with me about this and starts talking about reaching out the hotel for solutions when all I want to do is book something else and get on with my holiday - it seems to be a deliberate stalling tactic at that last minute. I have to mention credit card chargebacks and consumer complaints to get anywhere.

Eventually I get him to send me confirmation that they will refund me...and the only thing to their credit is that was processed very quickly.

Their app is now deleted from phone, along with their sister company booking.com!
 
I've used Agoda a reasonable amount in the past because they're often cheaper than other OTAs. While taking advantage of those prices, I've often had thoughts in the back of my mind that the prices might be too good to be true.

Thanks for the heads up. I will give Agoda a wider berth in future. I've already sworn off Booking.com for a few unrelated reasons...
 
You might want to add the complete suite of brands they trade under to the blacklist

Booking.com
Priceline.com
Agoda
Rentalcars.com
Kayak
OpenTable
Rocketmiles
FareHarbor
HotelsCombined
Cheapflights
momondo
 
After a couple of issues, we won't book anything other than base room via Agoda and ideally avoid them.

It seems there are problems with room mappings, we encountered this 2 years ago in Prague booking a 2BR apartment and ended up with a 1 BR apartment with just one bed and a sofa (not sofa bed) for the 3 of us. And last month in Chamonix booking a Mont Blanc facing room, we were allocated one without the view. On the former Agoda compensated us, on the latter the hotel wasn't full so put us instead in the right room. The hotel staff said it happens all the time with Agoda, and that they don't work with Agoda, it's done obliquely through third parties, and are trying to get pulled from the site without a lot of success.

But as a result - generally avoid - but if not only ever book base level room (in a non-smoking hotel) - if the wrong room is allocated then it's only an upside.

Never had this issue with booking.com or expedia.
 
It seems there are problems with room mappings
Which was essentially the issue here.

Garden pool villa became garden room in independent building down the street.

The price doesn't map though...because those rooms would never be $500 out of season.
 
Elevate your business spending to first-class rewards! Sign up today with code AFF10 and process over $10,000 in business expenses within your first 30 days to unlock 10,000 Bonus PayRewards Points.
Join 30,000+ savvy business owners who:

✅ Pay suppliers who don’t accept Amex
✅ Max out credit card rewards—even on government payments
✅ Earn & transfer PayRewards Points to 10+ airline & hotel partners

Start earning today!
- Pay suppliers who don’t take Amex
- Max out credit card rewards—even on government payments
- Earn & Transfer PayRewards Points to 8+ top airline & hotel partners

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements

Funnily enough I moved onto my next destination in Bali....booked via Trip.com and again had an issue.

Much less drastic...King Room became Twin Room. The hotel showed me the request that came through from Trip.com's third party supplier and sure enough it was for a twin.

The hotel was 100% full so couldn't do anything, but at least Trip were easy to message. They offered a small amount of compensation, I asked for more and they 2.5x the amount...$150 for pushing the beds together! They did also offer the option to rebook elsewhere. All of this achieved in the time I was doing check in formalities.
 
Funnily enough I moved onto my next destination in Bali....booked via Trip.com and again had an issue.

Much less drastic...King Room became Twin Room. The hotel showed me the request that came through from Trip.com's third party supplier and sure enough it was for a twin.

The hotel was 100% full so couldn't do anything, but at least Trip were easy to message. They offered a small amount of compensation, I asked for more and they 2.5x the amount...$150 for pushing the beds together! They did also offer the option to rebook elsewhere. All of this achieved in the time I was doing check in formalities.
That is a common problem with many of the OTAs - possibly more the issue with some property in that some rooms are sold as “Double/Twin”. In Europe, that can just mean the difference between pushing the beds together. Other places not so.

I make a point of requesting a double bed in the comments field.

Apart from the Booking.com data breach (😔), I’ve generally had no issues with Expedia/QF Hotels, Booking and more recently Trip.com for places we can’t book direct.

Never used Agoda and probably won’t now. I’m also trying not to use Booking but they do have a far broader range than Expedia > QF Hotels (even though QF uses Expedia).
 
Just wanted to share some details of a recent experience I had with Agoda...a company I have been booking with since at least 2009, if not before.

I booked 5 nights at beach resort in Seminyak, Bali. The room type was a 190sqm private pool villa, in a resort, and the room rate close to A$500p/n. I have stayed at this resort before, and certainly while I thought this was a good deal...it is not out of the range for similar properties in the same area.

36 hours before departure, call from Agoda. There's been an error. You can have absolutely the lowest room category in the hotel, a twin room, located in the satellite building a few minutes walk down the street. No you can't have any refund but you can have USD150 compensation total! The room they are offering me is currently for sale on their website at A$370 per night (with some advance booking, typically more like A$250)...but they can't understand why their $30 per night compensation offer doesn't sit well with me. I tell them no, and am prepared to be reasonable. I ask them to instead get me the best room category available...there are no villas left, but the suite category is available last minute at A$600pn. After a few minutes they revert with a "no" and upping their compensation offer to USD250. Then they stop responding to any emails or chat messages...closing any chats off with, "your case has been closed" type messages.

In desperation I call back some random number in Malaysia that called me previously and do manage to speak to customer service. The long and the short is that I then spend the next 90 minutes arguing with them that, the fact that my room rate was non-refundable has no bearing here as they are the ones that downgraded me from close to the highest room category to the absolute lowest...they insist over and over its non-refundable.

Ultimately I get to a very aggressive manager who again argues with me about this and starts talking about reaching out the hotel for solutions when all I want to do is book something else and get on with my holiday - it seems to be a deliberate stalling tactic at that last minute. I have to mention credit card chargebacks and consumer complaints to get anywhere.

Eventually I get him to send me confirmation that they will refund me...and the only thing to their credit is that was processed very quickly.

Their app is now deleted from phone, along with their sister company booking.com!
Why not book directly with that resort given you have been there before. Email with background and quoted prices - say how much you loved it . Likely they would have matched?
 
I used booking.com and Agoda in last 12 months. And also booking direct. Have had no issues with any of them. And Agoda gave me a price for Bali this month that was over a thousand less than any of the usuals or direct. That trip went off extremely well.

Yes my data did get breached with booking.com and I did get a fake WhatsApp message on one of those bookings but no real dramas in sorting that.

Hope that lasts. I have a real mix next year.
 
I've switched to Rove for the transferable miles but i sometimes use Agoda and Booking.com when they have the option to lock in the hotel but delay payment until a few days before the stay. we usually stay in more budget properties though and don't book the top category rooms.
 
Always book direct, or take the risk

I always book direct, except for the odd Qantas booking or Amex booking to use a travel credit

I try to, but sometimes this is not possible, or easy.

There's still some properties that lack a website, or one that works well.

I have never had a problem with 'booking' or its cheaper offshoot, Agoda. However it seems there are a growing number of travellers who do, especially with 'booking', so a timely warning.
 
I booked an apartment via Agoda in London in July, assume it’s an AirBnB style arrangement.
Arrived in London not having been given any door access codes or whatever (day of train travel prior so I’d sent a message or two & done a bit of looking around) … started chasing up, discovered the apartment was no longer being rented via Agoda (suspect it had been sold - or maybe “sold” as part of some tax-avoidance scheme, who knows).
So on a sunny July Saturday evening in London, which of course is never busy at that time of year … Agoda were willing to give me my money back. No offer of alternate accommodation or any sort of discount to deal with the cost to me of their screw-up, nothing.
 
I'm not a fan of the blanket advice to book direct. Booking direct does not guarantee zero problems. I recall a thread about Pullman Sydney asking the guest to pay more after the direct booking has been confirmed. Booking direct is not often good value as you miss out on OTA discounts. Booking direct is not even possible for most hotels outside the major hotel chains. Most of the time, OTAs are just easier. One-click no questions asked change of mind cancellations are just way too convenient. Anyway, we all have our personal preferences.
 
Last edited:

Become an AFF member!

Join Australian Frequent Flyer (AFF) for free and unlock insider tips, exclusive deals, and global meetups with 65,000+ frequent flyers.

AFF members can also access our Frequent Flyer Training courses, and upgrade to Fast-track your way to expert traveller status and unlock even more exclusive discounts!

AFF forum abbreviations

Wondering about Y, J or any of the other abbreviations used on our forum?

Check out our guide to common AFF acronyms & abbreviations.
Back
Top