But with a few drops of water?
I find it really strange that you enjoy, e.g., Laphroig, but are also happy with JW Red. Note I'm not being critical here - your taste buds are your own, of course, and I'm not into "snobbery" of any kind - just making a personal observation.
All the JWs above red have the same flaw, to my mind: all OK+ whiskeys, but all too expensive for what they are, easily outdone by others costing far less at each of their respective price points.
Agree that Glenlivet 18 is very nice - just finished a bottle unfortunately. Haven't tried Macallan 18, but it's on my "to buy when passing through non-Australian duty free" list. I found a new personal favourite this year - Glenmorangie Finealta. Sensational drop - but not available in Oz yet, as far as I know, and will likely be hideously expensive when it is.