Which premium economy airline is best

[Tooner]

I have tried CX, SQ, AC, QF and JL. Tops would be QF, then JL. The rest were kind of meh!

 

[MEL_Traveller]

I have tried CX, SQ, AC, QF and JL. Tops would be QF, then JL. The rest were kind of meh!

The champagne on JL and lounge access is a winner. I’m not a fan of shell seats though

 

[Tooner]

The champagne on JL and lounge access is a winner. I’m not a fan of shell seats though

The shell seats are …. Interesting. Overall quite comfortable and better than economy.

 

[bPeteb]

OP didn't bother coming back but I'll add my 5c.

As at today have flown QF, NZ and BA. Peter the QF and NZ seat over BA. QF catering over the other two. NZ for great service with QF a very close second. It helps being WP I reckon.

We're giving SQ PE a whirl on the way back from India in the new year. Mid-year AY from HKG to HEL and CX from YYZ to HKG. Looking forward to comparing.

 

[KLH]

We've done QF PE LAX/SYD (747 in 2012) and DFW/SYD (A380 in 2019) and both very comfy. Next year will be our first time with the refreshed cabins. The only negative which has been mentioned in reviews/other posts is lack of leg room.