Apologies in advance for the long post, but you can choose not to read it ...
There are wider implications to this 20% premium on direct ultra long haul flights.
It assumes PAX prefer the non-stop flights.
I suspect that many PAX will think they look like a good idea: until they take one.
I live in Perth but my partner lives in Paris so I am a fairly good test customer.
I had an open mind before my first trips on QF33/34.
However after one return trip I have chosen flights with a stop-over wherever possible.
I prefer to have a break, stretch my legs, enjoy the lounge, have a meal, take a shower and change clothes.
Maybe even do some shopping or, on a long stop-over, leave the airport and explore.
I am prepared to take 21-23 hours instead of 17 to achieve this.
Especially as QF offers essentially the same catering on a 17 hour ultra long haul flight as on any medium or long haul flight.
So that's one proper meal and one light meal.
Whereas if I fly PER-SIN-CDG I will be served four meals in the air and have access to a la carte dining in the SIN F lounge.
I don't want to pay a 20% premium to receive less service. And fewer points and SCs!
(Today's sale fares: 29,000 points & 260 SCS for $5,672 indirect versus 28,200 points & 240 SCs for $5,875 direct.)
(These aren't the fares I paid a week ago, luckily I paid over $1,000 less. Also fortunately it looks like the sale fare premium isn't 20%. Based on the fares I paid it was more like 10%.)
Of course this is a question of preference and I - and other consumers - can make this choice.
And if QF have misread the market then that is a normal commercial issue and supply and demand will determine the outcome.
However there are interactions with capacity and fleet provision and aircraft selection which all impact this.
Leaving aside temporary arrangements during the Israel/US war against Iran, there are no scheduled flights on QF metal between PER-CDG or PER-LHR with a stopover. QF relies on its partnership with EK to service this market (and as a side note i wonder how long that partnership will survive project sunrise, which seems designed to sideline EK and its hub-and-spoke model).
PAX from PER fly on a flight PER-SIN and then connect to another flight SIN-CDG or SIN-LHR.
However those flights are scheduled as flights SYD-SIN-CDG or SYD-SIN-LHR.
For example QF1 and, during the war, QF219 & QF255.
So they arrive in SIN with PAX on board. Many of whom continue on to CDG/LHR.
Hence there is limited capacity for PAX from PER to join those flights.
For my upcoming trip, I have booked PER-SIN-CDG as a business sale fare.
However for the return, the only fares available via SIN were full fare Business Flex.
These are selling for just under $10,000 for the return alone.
Luckily there was a Business Sale Fare available on QF34 on one date only so i was able to book that for less than $6,000.
So in this case the direct fare was lower because a different fare class was available.
While I avoided the higher fare I am still paying a surcharge on the sale fare to fly direct.
My point is not to have a whinge about the options I had or the fare I paid at a peak period.
The point is how complex the question of capacity ex-PER can be and how this might be impacted by project sunrise and fleet changes.
Unless project sunrise generates a whole new market, some PAX will stop flying via SIN and fly SYD-LHR direct.
That is, after all, the whole design intent. Demand for flights via SIN will drop.
Although I imagine QF hope some of the PAX on the project sunrise flights will come from other airlines, not other QF flights.
At around the same time, QF will start retiring A380s and start replacing them with A350s and B787s.
So even if they maintain the same number of indirect flights via SIN, capacity will drop.
And the smaller aircraft don't provide the buffer that the huge A380 does.
This may make it even harder for PAX from PER to find seats on flights to Europe via SIN.
If the drop in capacity due to aircraft changes is more than the drop in demand due to the start of direct flights.
Leaving them with little option but to book the direct flights and pay the 20% premium.
In summary, QF will end up with a fleet optimised for a network comprising thin, long haul, direct routes.
Which may not service other routes as well, and which may impact other cities more than it impacts SYD.