If four are traveling together and sharing costs I would just go by cab.
Flat Fare from John F. Kennedy (JFK) Airport:
For trips between (to and from) Manhattan and JFK International Airport, the flat fare is $52.00 plus any tolls using Rate Code 2 on the meter. A NY State Tax Surcharge of $.50 will be added to each trip.
I've used Super Shuttle but that's probably more economical when travelling solo (and a bit slower).
Just check you can fit your luggage in a car or cab.
G'day,
Can any one please recommend the best method to get from JFK to our hotel near Times Square?
There is four of us traveling.
AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements
I've used the limo service Dial7 a number of times - wouldn't do it any other way now.
Beats standing in line waiting for a cab or trying to conquer the subway.
New York City Car & Limousine Service | Manhattan, Brooklyn, NJ & NYC Limo & Car Services