Damaged bag - how to claim

luxury-lizard

Established Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2013
Posts
1,038
Qantas
Bronze
Virgin
Red
There are several threads on this subject, but I'm looking for advice. Yesterday on arrival at BNE (from SYD) I found my large duffle bag (with a frame and wheels) had the zipper ripped off (one of the pull tabs) and it was gaping open and could not be re-closed. The baggage handlers obviously realised this had happed and rescued the bag and pulled it aside before the contents spilled out.

Now a Virgin agent paged me - she stated that this was not Virgin's fault and clearly (to her) the padlock I used to secure both pull tabs together must have gotten stuck in the "mechanism". I said "you've got to be kidding" - anyway she made a note in my PNR (for me to follow up later) and fortunately gave me another suitcase which someone had left with them (it had some damage but was still very useable). So I transferred the contents and took the damaged duffle with me (as well as the replaced one) - I believe the zip pull tab can be fixed/replaced.

Now I'm not sure what to do next - should I make a formal claim NOW (I'm out of town till next week) or wait till I find out if the bag can be repaired and at what cost. I have a distinct feeling Virgin will give me the "bum's rush" on this.
 
Read our AFF credit card guides and start earning more points now.

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements

wait till I find out if the bag can be repaired
Yes, basically they will say to take it to a particular luggage shop.
Shop often say cant be repaired and you will then get compo based on the depreciated value of the bag.

You will need for claim:
Property irregularity report from airport - need to report it within the baggage reclaim area.
Photo of damage
Flight details
Proof of purchase of bag.
 
I just read the VA ‘damaged bag’ section in their website.

I’m not sure it’s legal?

They say VA accepts no liability for scratches and dents, damage to handles, wheels etc etc.

They don’t appear to mention any caveat.

I’m pretty sure they have to accept liability in cases of negligence or mishandling. Not something they can contract out of.
 
quick follow up - I clicked on the link provided by @AIRwin (thank you) and the first page listed Virgin's T&Cs on claiming damage to baggage - one item is Zips are not covered - well that leaves me out in the cold - as the pull tab was ripped off the zipper leaving the whole case wide open and impossible to close. In fact there are so many exclusions I can't see Virgin ever taking responsibility for damage. Anyway - since the bag is quite new (only used a couple of times) I'll see if I can get it repaired on my return to Sydney - in the mean time I need to find some gaffer tape to close it (even though empty) so I can check it on my return flight. Fortunately I'm flying business class so I can check an extra bag.
 
quick follow up - I clicked on the link provided by @AIRwin (thank you) and the first page listed Virgin's T&Cs on claiming damage to baggage - one item is Zips are not covered - well that leaves me out in the cold - as the pull tab was ripped off the zipper leaving the whole case wide open and impossible to close. In fact there are so many exclusions I can't see Virgin ever taking responsibility for damage. Anyway - since the bag is quite new (only used a couple of times) I'll see if I can get it repaired on my return to Sydney - in the mean time I need to find some gaffer tape to close it (even though empty) so I can check it on my return flight. Fortunately I'm flying business class so I can check an extra bag.
That’s why i mentioned above, im not sure those exclusions are even legal.

VA cannot contract itself out of negligence, nor can it contract itself out of consumer law.

Minor damage, wear and tear etc are to be expected. But for major damage, someone, or something, somehow caused that damage.

Don’t see how VA can escape liability.
 
Does an airline have to take responsibility for airport mechanisms? I genuinely don’t know, but think I’ve seen in some jurisdictions that the airline is responsible for the entire period they have your checked luggage.

The airline will clearly claim straight up that they don’t because:
1. We accepted your bag from you when you checked in.
2. But then it is conveyed to the ramp via ‘airport’ owned facilities.
3. Our baggage handlers (company or contractors - doesn’t make any difference) then load it onto the aircraft.
4. Our company is then again responsible for getting it off the aircraft.
5. But it then again disappears into the realm of airport responsibility to be deposited into the collection belts.

They probably have a pretty strong case if it was a zip being forcibly opened or destroyed as a baggage handler is not likely to do that. A sorting/routing machine is more likely.

So, unless there is some way to hold the airport responsible for its facilities, it’s back to my original question.
 
Does an airline have to take responsibility for airport mechanisms? I genuinely don’t know, but think I’ve seen in some jurisdictions that the airline is responsible for the entire period they have your checked luggage.

The airline will clearly claim straight up that they don’t because:
1. We accepted your bag from you when you checked in.
2. But then it is conveyed to the ramp via ‘airport’ owned facilities.
3. Our baggage handlers (company or contractors - doesn’t make any difference) then load it onto the aircraft.
4. Our company is then again responsible for getting it off the aircraft.
5. But it then again disappears into the realm of airport responsibility to be deposited into the collection belts.

They probably have a pretty strong case if it was a zip being forcibly opened or destroyed as a baggage handler is not likely to do that. A sorting/routing machine is more likely.

So, unless there is some way to hold the airport responsible for its facilities, it’s back to my original question.
I think you’re right… the answer is ‘yes’ they are.

The Montreal Convention specifically includes it as the luggage is in the case or the airline. No reason to think domestic is carved out from that with different rules.
 
that’s right, in my response I pointed out the Montréal convention was international.

But you haven’t answered the question of whether a damaged bag is covered for domestic travel in the same way.
I am not a lawyer and won’t give legal advice on that basis, it’s a minefield I prefer to stay away from. Having said that I note the CACL act as linked, specifically “Liability of the carrier in respect of baggage”. Section 29
 
I am not a lawyer and won’t give legal advice on that basis, it’s a minefield I prefer to stay away from. Having said that I note the CACL act as linked, specifically “Liability of the carrier in respect of baggage”. Section 29
It looks like 29(2)(b) will cover Scarlett’s question… the period of carriage by air is any time the baggage is in the carriers possession, whether on board or elsewhere.
 

Become an AFF member!

Join Australian Frequent Flyer (AFF) for free and unlock insider tips, exclusive deals, and global meetups with 65,000+ frequent flyers.

AFF members can also access our Frequent Flyer Training courses, and upgrade to Fast-track your way to expert traveller status and unlock even more exclusive discounts!

AFF forum abbreviations

Wondering about Y, J or any of the other abbreviations used on our forum?

Check out our guide to common AFF acronyms & abbreviations.
Back
Top