The Trans Tasman crossing - a tale of two airlines

Status
Not open for further replies.

Justinf

Established Member
Joined
Sep 8, 2009
Posts
2,011
OK, so I'd had enough of the daily grind and had plenty of annual leave up my sleeve, so I decided to take all of July off and look for an inexpensive destination to take my 12-year-old daughter for a short holiday. Queensland is overpriced, although I do love Queensland, it's really gone downhill in the tourism stakes in my opinion and is horribly overpriced. So it was cheaper to look at New Zealand than in my own country.
I chose Wellington. It was my first overseas trip back in 1990 and the thrill of getting my daughter her first passport and her first out-country-experience was too good to pass up.
I'm a bit of a Virgin regular. I have Gold status and while I will seek to fly them if either port has a Lounge, I am not unknown to search around and fly with another carrier if the price is right or if the time is more appropriate. The best I could do for this trip was to fly Virgin over (via AKL) and Qantas back (direct).
In hindsight I should have just taken the 8.50am direct WLG service, but when you are dealing with a tween, that extra 70 minutes in bed can make all the difference, so I chose the 10am to AKL. It was a mistake. I should have just taken control and booked it and told her to deal with it, but we live and learn.
This trip report is not really a report on the actual trips but more a comparison between the two experiences. I also didn't take a lot of photos like I normally do. Both flights were in a 738 and we've all flown on this cramped bird haven't we? I didn't feel the need to show pics of the cabin of an aircraft that everyone here reading would know like the backs of their hands. What I should have done, was take a pic or two of the Air NZ A320 bird, but I didn't due to exhaustion and not being bothered to get my camera of my bag from the overhead locker.
So here were go.

Thusday, July 5
Woke at 5am and ended up leaving the house just before 6am for the 75-minute trip to Melbourne airport fromour home in Barwon Heads. Well, it normally takes that time, but a truck had decided to break down on the West Gate, which added 15 minutes to the trip. Got to the long-term car park at around 7.30am. The parking attendant directed me to turn left, but as usual, I ignored him and turned right. I like to park near the front of the complex and walk to the terminal and I wasn't going to be told where to go unless it was actually necessary in which case I would have followed the rules. There are always one or two parks around that area and today was no exception. With a 10-minute walk to the terminal in the crisp early morning of outer suburban Melbourne, it woke us from our dreary slumber.
We arrived at the check-in counter and with Gold status I walked to the priority check-in queue and was processed almost immediately. Seats 3B and 3C for us on this 738 that had 8 premium econony seats, but no business cabin as is the usual status of these Trans Tasman journeys on Virgin. Priority security and customs cards were issued and we flew through security, but customs was a 10-minute wait and then we were into the duty-free area that seems to overwhelm once you are inside. I tried to really pump the whole 'international terminal' WOW factor to my 12-year-old and tried to make it as exciting as possible. You know, when you go through those doors it means you are going to another country kind of 'wow' but she didn't really buy it. It was early, it was her school holidays and she had been sleeping in for the first days of it and was not into this early morning thing.
As a Gold member, we had access to the Air NZ Koru Lounge, so with us both feeling hungry, we made a beeline downstairs. Once inside, I was quite impressed with the lounge itself. It wasn't very busy and it was quiet (for the most part) except for two young children (about 3 and 4 years of age) who thought it appropriate to yell and scream pretty much the whole time, with little intervention from their mother. Grrrrrr.
There was a reasonable selection of hot food including eggs, sausages and beans, with the obligatory pancake machine. No barista coffee though, so I had to make do with the machine, which churned out a very ordinary brew. The bar was also self-serve, including spirits, and although I will admit it crossed my mind, at 8.30am it was just too early for me at that stage.
Here's my heaping plate of eggs on toast with a very average machine-made coffee, which I didn't finish.
korubreakfast.jpg




Boarding was called for the flight to Auckland and it seemed orderly enough. We went to the gate and went through the priority check-in lane. This is what makes my daughter impressed. Special treatment and while her dad can maintain Gold status, she is always happy to avail of the Lounge facilities and go to the front of all the queues.
Row 3 on this aircraft is just behind the two PE rows. It has more legroom and it is more roomy. We occupied the middle and aisle and there was a gentleman on the window side.
I knew this was basically going to be little more than a domestic style flight across the Tasman. Push back was on time and soon we were gone and out across the ditch. There was no IFE on this aircraft. Fortuntaley I had preloaded my iPad with movies for Miss 12, and the plan for me was to hire a dig-eplayer which I had looked at the movie selection in the July edition of Voyeur online and the Hunger Games was due to be shown on this contraption. At $15 to hire, they are expensive. But we soon were told that the July movies had not been loaded and the devices were still loaded with June's movies (which I took a look at and didn't see anything I liked). This was disappointing. If you are going to advertise something, do it. It's not that hard is it? So I had to be content with my iPod as Miss 12 giggled her way through Johnny English and Space Kids 3.
The 'meal' service came around and of course in economy, it is pay as you go. There was only one person in PE, in seat 1F.
I opted for a meat pie and a Bundy & Cola and Miss 12 had some crisps. This set me back $25. Ouch! I have to say,though, the pie was very nice. Real chunks of beef, although it was a while before I could dig my teeth into it, it was so hot. I guess they nuked it too long. But at those prices, it was my first and last order from the trolley.
483391_3674321050714_351590843_n.jpg

The flight was smooth, and there was one other trolley run. What I found unacceptable was that there was no water run. As you can't take a water bottle onboard (unless it's purchased once you get past customs - I guess I could have filled one for free in the Koru Lounge - duh!) you rely on water being served onboard. I had to ask three times for water and the offerings were so meagre, I needn't have bothered. Yes, this is a criticism. About 20 minutes from Auckland, the captain told us that the airport was shrouded in heavy fog and it was at the minimum level required to land safely. He said there was a very good chance we could abort our landing and divert to Wellington. I wondered (as WLG was our final destination) if we would be allowed to disembark there and retrieve our bags if this was the case, but deep down I knew this was about a 0.00000001% chance of happening. I asked the FA anyway and she had no clue. I then asked the more appropriate of the two questions and enquired about what would happen if we missed our connecting flight from AKL to WLG on Air NZ (all booked on the one ticket) and she simply shrugged her shoulders and said she didn't know. Great! Glad to know. For me, it wasn't so much the hassle of not knowing, it was trying to explain to Miss 12 what would happen if we would have to overnight in Auckland or be able to grab our luggage and just end the journey in Wellington and bypass Auckland altgother. In fact the entire crew had little idea and I don't think I saw a smile for the while 3 and a half hours.
Fortuntaley the runway appeared and the pilots were able to execute a perfect landing much to the relief of everyone onboard. Hooray!
Disembarking was swift (they allowed the sole PE passenger off first). So much for priority baggage. Both our bags (marked with 'priority' tag were one of the last onto the conveyer belt. Fortunately the process of rechecking our bags at the AKL international terminal bag drop was painless. It was then either wait for a bus to take us to the domestic terminal or walk for 15 minutes. We walked and it took more like 10 minutes in the crisp fresh Auckland air.
Upon reaching the domestic terminal it became apparent that the fog was playing havoc with all flights in and out of AKL. The line to get through security was immense but it moved surprisingly quickly (Australians take note! Prepare for this BEFORE you reach the conveyor belt, not when you get to the conveyor belt. Kiwis seem to have this all sorted and are very organised, unlike my fellow countrymen and women). We already had our BPs and being Virgin Gold, hightailed it to the Koru Lounge which resembled a zoo. We had to sit on the floor and it was obvious that many flights were affected by the fog. In fact they ended up closing check-in such was the backlog. Just closed check-in for all flights completely. Fortunately our 6pm service to WLG was scheduled as running on time. In the Koru Lounge I had a couple of Mac's Gold beers and some sausage rolls while Miss 12 availed herself of some of the delicious sweet slices. Our gate was just outside the Lounge so I could tell when it was ready for boarding even though there was no announcement. After a 45-minute hiatus of no check-in, this was lifted and people were now permitted to check in for their flights. After an hour in the Koru Lounge, I was glad to be out (it was just so busy) and in line boarding an A320 painted in all black. Seats 10B and 10C (again all black) and we settled in nicely. There was ample legroom here. 33in I am told and Miss 12 quickly curled up into a ball and fell asleep. Unfortauntely we had missed our place in the take-off queue and we ended up departing at 6.30pm. Miss 12 slept through take off and most of the 50-minute hop down to Welly. A simple snack of cheese and crackers and two grapes were served with a choice of beverage. I chose sav blanc and while it was nice, it would barely have filled a thimble. The flight was smooth and was full, mainly with businesspeople returning from doing their thing in Auckland.
Landing was smooth and we had a great view Wellington. Once again the concept of priority baggage was a contradiction. One bag was loaded quickly, the other was last (I was beginning to think it had gone missing).
Thumbs up to Air New Zealand. A big meh to Virgin Australia NZ.

So after a lovely holiday, we were ready for the Qantas flight back across the ditch and home.

Monday July 9
We arrived at the airport at 11.30am for our 3.10pm QF38 to Melbourne. Check in didn't open until noon so we sat and chilled.
Once check in did open we got up and were 2nd in line. There was also a QF flight to Sydney leaving just after ours. We could have upgraded to business for an extra $450 each. Trust me, I considered it, but albeit briefly. Mrs Justinf would not have approved at spending $900. We were assigned seats 20E and 20F and wasted time in the domestic part of the airport spending our remaining NZ$ on beer (for me) and knickknacks in the shops for Miss 12.
The international boarding gates were not open until about 90 minutes before our flight. Eventually we went through and got sucked in to the temptations of duty free and I bought a NZ$249 pair of Panasonic noise-cancelling headphones and bought the wife a bottle of Johnny Walker.
Once into the international terminal area we sat at the cafe-bar for a while and then it was time to board.
It soon became obvious to me once the 738 aircraft door had closed then Miss 12 and I had the row to ourselves, which meant I was able to move to the aisle seat, leaving the middle seat vacant.
This proved to be a godsend for me as the legroom on this aircraft was not as ample as the previous two flights. 31in at an absolute maxiumum although I would be interested to know of the exact measurement. I am 6'1" so I am no giant, but I am not short either and thankfully the spare seat next to me meant I could stretch my legs out,otherwise it wouldhave been a very uncomfortable 4 hours indeed.




legroomqf.jpg
 

Attachments

  • 09072012232.jpg
    09072012232.jpg
    89.7 KB · Views: 400
Last edited:
This aircraft had seat-back IFE and although I had planned with movies still unwatched on my iPad, Miss 12 almost wet herself with excitement when she realised the Hunger Games was one of the movies on offer. My wife and I have considered this movie to be inappropriate for a 12-year-old to watch (my wife had seen it, I hadn't) but somehow I relented. Surely it couldn't be worse than the Harry Potter movies? Am I a bad parent?
The meal service started shortly after take-off, which was smooth for this Qantas flight, which I understand is operated by Jetconnect. The cabin crew seemed to be all Kiwi and immaculately attired and smiling. Great start.
The meal was a choice between Korean beef with rice or a vegetarian lasagne. Both Miss 12 and I chose the beef and it was delicious, although a little sparse.
mealqantas2.jpg

Miss 12 lapping it up (it was me who polished off the remainder of her meal).


livqantas5.jpg


I had a nice shiraz and Miss 12 had lemonade. We ate and settled in to watch the movie. I decided to watch the Hunger Games as well, partly because I wanted to anyway, but also to keep an eye on it and be prepared to reach over and switch the 'off' button to Miss 12's screen if I deemed it too gory. There were two scenes that were disturbing but overall I didn't think it was as bad as made out and Miss 12 ended up loving the movie (Miss 12's mum was not a happy camper when we returned home that night and found out what she had watched on the flight - guess who got into trouble for that?). I used my new earphones and was slightly disappoiinted at the quality. Maybe I was just expecting to be blown away by a pair of AUS$200 headphones.
After dinner the ice creams were wheeled out. Yum!

qantasicecream.jpg

I had another red wine (complimentary) and pretty soon were nearing the end of what was a very good flight, with professional crew.

View attachment 8417


While waiting for the loo just before our descent in MEL I poked my head into the back galley and congratulated the two crew members who were preparing for landing. Told them I was a Gold Virgin member, but for any Trans Tasman crossings in the future, I will be choosing Qantas. They were genuinely chuffed and seemed to respond really well to the positive feedback. It made me feel good that I made them feel good for doing a terrific job.
15 minutes later the young male FA discreetly presented me with a wrapped bottle of wine as a gift as a way 'of saying thankyou for your great feedback and making our day'. Wow! I didn't do it to get a present, but I certainly accepted with good grace and thanked him very much. I liked how he presented it discreetly so other passengers wouldn't see. I enjoy giving feedback, particularly positive feedback and seeing the receptiveness in people's eyes and their faces. It is such a small gesture to perform, but it leaves a lasting legacy on people who deserve it. We are all human beings who feel the same emotions.
When I got home, I opened the wrapping and out popped a bottle of Ben Glaetzer Bishop shiraz. I LOVE Glaetzer's wines. The Wallace in particular is a regular on my wine rack at home when I can find it for around $20 and I have always wanted to try to the Bishop, but the $35-plus price tag sometimes put me off, although I don't mind spending good money for good wine and was always going to try it sooner or later. Now I get to try it for free. Thanks Qantas.

Copy of gllaetzer.jpg


All in all, it was a great little holiday. Wellington is a beaufitul city. We found plenty of things to do, it is safe to walk around and people were lovely. The coffee was ordinary (but hey, who can compete with Melbourne?), but the food was wonderful. Welly reminds of a bigger Hobart. Most importantly Miss 12 loved her holiday.
So given a choice of crossing the Tasman again in the future, it's no contest really. Qantas wins hands down, even for the extra $50 per seat that I paid. Coming back to MEL I had the choice of a direct 6am Virgin flight or a direct Qantas 3.10pm flight for about $50 extra. No brainer when it's a leisure flight and you don't need to be in MEL in the morning to do business.
In fact Virgin needs to lift its game in this market or just pull out completely. The current product is substandard and a bit of an embarrassment to an otherwise excellent airline. I will continue to use Virgin for my domestic flights, mainly because of my Gold status, which allows Lounge access and fly ahead options, but I will continue to monitor Qantas' schedules and prices and will not hestitate to jump ship if I need to for certain flights. I have done a few QF flights recently and the product has impressed me,while Virgin also seem to have lifted their game. Good news for the punter I guess.
The Trans Tasman flights are that awkward length where they are long enough to be more than just a short hop, but short enough to not need too many frills.
Virgin's seats were more comfortable and they were about $50 cheaper, but Qantas won with superior service, complimentary meals and drinks, free IFE and smiling, professional crew.
 
Last edited:
Good report.

I just want to note that the meals and drink on qantas while complimentary, did cost $50. Just saying.


Sent from the Throne
 
Good report.

I just want to note that the meals and drink on qantas while complimentary, did cost $50. Just saying.


Sent from the Throne
of course. nothing is for free, except for a $35 bottle of Glaetzer Bishop ;-)
 
of course. nothing is for free, except for a $35 bottle of Glaetzer Bishop ;-)

Nice! :cool:

I guess it would just make me feel the airlines are the same. But the emotional part of me says no to paying for food on an international flight.


Sent from the Throne
 
Nice! :cool:

I guess it would just make me feel the airlines are the same. But the emotional part of me says no to paying for food on an international flight.


Sent from the Throne
I agree and this is why the Virgin experience was basically a domestic flight that required a passport to board and disembark. Call me a bit strange, but I want an international flight to feel like an international flight. QF did. DJ didn't.
To be honest, the extra $50 spent on QF more than paid for itself. When you add $15 for a dig-eplayer and around $40 for a simple sandwich/pie and drink for two people, it is probably more expensive for the inferior product. The ice cream at the end of the nicely preperared hot meal was just an added extra and the seat-back IFE was far better than any dig-eplayer.
Don't get me wrong. I am a Virgin fan, just not the Trans Tasman product. I just thought I'd do a comparison trip report, that's all based on my perceptions and my individual preferences and of course taking into the consideration of travelling with a tween who at that age is starting to be very much aware of her surroundings and what's good and what's not.
 
That's a great comparo. Certainly Virgin need to do something with their trans-tasman offering.

Re: food vs $50 - you paid $25 for a pie, chips and drink on the first flight. So factoring the spend on board, you got more food (plus the free red wine bottle).

Frankly, it'd be worth the $50 just to fly at a better time!
 
The Frequent Flyer Concierge team takes the hard work out of finding reward seat availability. Using their expert knowledge and specialised tools, they'll help you book a great trip that maximises the value for your points.

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements

Great report. Agree re: virgin TT product although I highly recommend Air NZ if you still want the perks and SCs.
 
Have to say that in terms of service across TT, EK Y on SYD-AKL A380 is still the best. Heaps of room for Y, secluded Y cabin, tons of food for 3 hour flight and amazing ICE system. The price is comparable to QF (sometimes cheaper). Plus 30kg luggage thrown in.

Of course OP is from MEL and doesn't have this service in A380 yet.
 
Velocity points still haven't been credited. It's been a week. Anyone know how long this usually takes?
 
Velocity points still haven't been credited. It's been a week. Anyone know how long this usually takes?

I assume you mean the Air NZ sector. It depends on the booking class. Q H M in discount Y and Y B in Y Other booking classes earn zero

Domestic New Zealand Flights:
Fare type
Points earn rate per mile​
Discount Economy (Q, H, M)
0.75 Velocity Points​
Economy (Y, B)
1 Velocity Point​

Please allow 14 days before raising a retrospective Points claim with Air New Zealand.
 
Yes, sorry, I didn't make myself very clear did I? I have not been awarded any points or SCs for the Virgin Australia (MEL-AKL) sector, nor the Air NZ (AKL-WEL) sector. I guess they will turn up eventually though.
 
The last Pacific Blue flight I took was BNE-VLI and the points took 48 hours to post.
 
Nice report.
I am quite happy with the QF trans Tasman offering ( BNE - AKL ) only did one VA flight, not excited about doing it again. But then I have ( some) status with QF so lounge access and priority check in / boarding in AKL is a big plus for me.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top