AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements
Loyalty bonus SC do count to lifetime status, but not to P1
The whole point of bonus SC promos is to encourage flying that might not otherwise have been booked. I would be O.K. with it not counting to P1 as I'm unlikely to get that even with a DSC promo, but having it not count to lifetime status wouldn't make much sense as that's one of the drivers to encourage additional flying under such a promo. If they offered LTP I could understand them not wanting DSC promos to count towards that, but they don't offer Lifetime Platinum.
Lifetime Gold status is not my concern. It's my Platinum status that looks and feels more like Gold status everyday that concerns me.I can understand that you don't want one as a LTG JohnK, but some of us are still a long way off LTG and would like to get there a bit quicker.
Of course the main purpose of DSC is for status for the current/next year, but LT status for some e.g. me is a secondary consideration. That little bit of extra value that makes chasing status in the short term worthwhile.In my view you're making one very large assumption - that a majority of people notice or care about LT status.