The latest choice magazine has published an article stating that current frequent flyer programs in Australia are not worth it. They use example of
Virgin Australia Velocity Rewards which would require 13 round trip flights from SYD-LAX to get enough points to get one economy SYD-LAX flight with points. With Qantas, it would take only 7. They also stated that frequent flyer miles are virtual currency and they frowned upon the new trend to offer products for frequent flyer miles as often they worth far less than the miles used to redeem them are worth. They give examples of a 129 dollar microwave costing four SYD-LAX return flights on Virgin's Velocity Rewards. Qantas has similiar redemption offers like a 439 dollar telesivion that would cost six SYD-LAX return trips. Virgin was quick to point out that a flight with
Etihad SYD-LHR would accumulate enough miles to book 2 trips SYD-MEL.
This is an interesting point that I'm sure has been made countless times on forums like this, and Choice is no frequent traveller as they didn't mention status tiers benefits per se (just the fact you got more points with status). Their analysis is quite obtuse as it always is. I did start to wonder if I just went with the lowest fare and not bother with loyality whether or not I would come out ahead. Luckily
Etihad has the best sales to Europe in first/business class compared to Qantas, but sometimes Qantas does have good deals. Would saving 1000-2000 dollars every one of 6 flights to LHR make up for the added miles I would get on
Etihad which would be about 54,000 miles. Currently it would take 7 first class trips SYD-LHR to get one first class award SYD-LHR. It would take a year flying
Etihad to get one first class ticket, but as I only see Qantas fares lower than
Etihad in first class maybe once a year I'd only end up with 1000-2000 dollars spare (which is not enough to buy another first class ticket). So in my case it is better to stick with one airline if you just analyse it with dollars, frequecny of trips, but ignore status benefits etc. Personally I prefer
Etihad's first class compared to what I've heard about Qantas' first class so I think I come ahead in all fronts!
http://www.choice.com.au/reviews-an...irline-travel/frequent-flyer-points/page.aspx