How does Marriott treat you as an elite?

albatross710

Established Member
Joined
May 15, 2004
Posts
3,704
I thought it might be nice to have a thread to record Marriott performance for members:

Status: Platinum Challenge
Property: Marriott Cebu
Date: 25-27 Sept 2012
Rate: 54999, Weekend Rate.
Booked: Double Guest Room
Upgraded: Executive Floor with Lounge Access
Received: Breakfast in the restaurant or the lounge.

The standard letter given to me at check-in provided the following Platinum benefits:
Complimentary breakfast
Lounge access for coughtails 5:30pm-7:30pm
Two pieces of pressing per stay
2 hours of boardroom use
Basic Business services

All up and enjoyable stay. The extra benefits of membership make this a great place to stay over and above the many lower cost but basic local offerings.

Alby
 
The Frequent Flyer Concierge team takes the hard work out of finding reward seat availability. Using their expert knowledge and specialised tools, they'll help you book a great trip that maximises the value for your points.

AFF Supporters can remove this and all advertisements

Dates: 22-24 Jun 2016 (Actually booked 22-25 but urgent SOS to return home so checked out after 2 days)
Property: Portman Ritz Carlton Shanghai
Booked: Deluxe Room
Rate: Goldman Sachs Rate ;) CNY1173.91+10% Surcharge subject to 6% VAT per night with I daily breakfast -
Received: Less than Deluxe Room - Multiples botts water / plate of hors d'oeurves
Marriott Status: Silver

WOW - is this hotel ever dated - it has been built 20+yrs and not a cent spent on rooms / restaurant in that time - I was just amazed how dated it was - clearly stuck in a time warp.

BUT - ALL staff in ALL areas fabulous.

On return to Oz I received an email containing survey to complete - I did that - one question on survey was 'Do you intend to post trip report online?' and a list of online options. I really had not even contemplated posting report but after reading that did indeed post on TA. PRC GM responded to my report and requested I contact him directly - my email to him:
Mr General Manager
I posted a report on TripAdvisor re my stay at PRC May 22-24. I was staying in Room 3210. This was my first ever stay at PRC – I have visited Shanghai hundreds of times over last 20yr period – my usual hotels now are Le Royal Meridien and Waldorf Astoria.
Whilst the room at PRC was reasonably spacious it just appeared very very dated – particularly that tiny glass shower cabinet that comes from a bygone era. This was a very disappointing feature.
Also I thought the décor of Portmans on ground floor for breakfast was also so dated – and indeed the buffet nowhere near as broad as Le Meridien.
One morning I had to wait 10mins for whole wheat bread to be replenished and next morn just no whole wheat bread at all – I cannot eat white bread.
Again very disappointing for a 5* hotel.

BUT

Staff in all areas on all levels were FABULOUS – very helpful and very polite – Concierge / Bell Service did indeed do a great service for me in helping me out with a huge carton I needed to transport back to Australia
Yours faithfully
Cruiser Elite
Response from General Manager
Dear Mr. Elite – many thanks for replying to my post. I am in conversation with our Owners about an obviously much needed renovation of the hotel and we hope to start the process in 2017. This will mean an extensive renovation of all public areas and restaurants. We understand that there needs to be a perfect blend of software with hardware and I know currently we are not in harmony here but look to rectify this in the hopefully near future. Again, many thanks for your comments.

It pains me that you didn’t enjoy your stay so would love to compensate you in some way, (and I know that this was not your intent with your review). However, I am going to credit your credit card for room and tax for one night. My hope is that when our renovations are completed we can welcome you back to our hotel.

Regards,
General Manager
The Portman Ritz-Carlton, Shanghai
WOW - simply WOW - how is that for recovery? He has already secured my next stay in Shanghai - how could I not give them another go? Am tipping I won't be in 3210 next visit.
 
Last edited:
No Marriott status apart from basic level. Staying Marriott Casamagna Cancun currently. Recovering from Cuba cycling trip. Staff great though everyone has a hand out for a tip. Free fast WiFi. Great breakfast buffet ..Japanese, Mexican, American, omelette range, huge fruit selection...great pool, and tiny surf...very relaxing for sore muscles.
 
Fiji Marriott Resort Momi Bay - SPG Gold member (Marriott Gold)

Opened 3 weeks ago.

Booked - [FONT=&amp]Duplex Lagoon Front Bure, Larger Guest room, 1 King, Lagoon Front view, Waterfront
Received - [/FONT]
Over-water Lagoon Bure, Villa, Over-water view, Lagoon view, Balcony.

Also received 2 x complimentary coffee's per day / 20% Discount voucher for all food & Drinks / 20% off SPA.
Choice of food & Drinks to room or Points as bonus.
Free Wi-fi & Free Buffet Breakfast.

This hotel will set new standards of accommodation in Fiji. Safe to say we were more than happy with the way Marriott had treated us. Incredible experience.
 
No status at all but the Renaissance St Pancras, London was exceptional for the night I was there.

Just an overnight stopover really between a train from Cornwall and a train next day to Edinburgh (yes, we like train travel). Booked a Pre-Paid rate but not billed until check-in - the Hotel was full so did not expect an upgrade but was offered a free bottle of wine as only had a Twin Room in the new wing. The room was large (for London) and very modern, except for the shower over the bath (you needed a step ladder to step into the bath, it was so high). Super fast WiFi in room but the historical part of the old Railway Hotel built around the equally impressive St. Pancras station was a real experience. The Lounge is in the old booking hall and the roof over reception matched the station next door. The staff were the friendliest I have encountered on this trip - nothing like the Londoners of old when we lived there.
 
Hi,

Do you receive the Marriott gold status benefits if booking an award/points stay?

Cheers

Yes. You still get all the benefits.

Related question to these posts from some time ago... I have my first points stay coming up as an MR Plat member. I know the entitlements will be honoured, like exec lounge, premium internet, etc. but does anyone have any experiences with room upgrades? I'd have selected a higher category to start with, but it's always frustrated me you generally can't select anything but the lead-in room category with an award stay, with most of the big chains.

Cheers,
Matt.
 
I am upgraded almost 95% of the time with Marriott, jumping a few room levels. I chose the cheapest room and rarely do I ever get it, only if they are "packed to the gunnels". When I do use points its the same thing, upgrade.
 
I am upgraded almost 95% of the time with Marriott, jumping a few room levels. I chose the cheapest room and rarely do I ever get it, only if they are "packed to the gunnels". When I do use points its the same thing, upgrade.

Cool - thanks, leadman. I'll of course report back here after that stay (it's not for another 3 months yet) and let the forum know!
 
Thanks. I sort of fell into the Marriott system as I spent some time years ago in the US in their cheaper Residence Inn hotels which built up the profile quickly. Then travelling thought Asia in a higher role JW's and that became the second home. I sort of regretted not picking SPG or others earlier, but the merger was brilliant news.
I cannot fault the Marriott chain as they have been very good to me and rarely had a problem and even then it is fixed with little fuss. In NYC the other week at the Lexington, their signature range, staff were just not focussed at the front desk and there was a bit of a stuff up. I made no complaint as I realise a "squeezy" hotel in hectic NYC can have its bad days. When the survey came around I wrote some honest comments; received note from Manager + 40,000 points!
 
Status: Gold
Property: Zurich Marriott
Booked: Superior Twin, Main Building
Upgraded: Nil. Not even a room with a river view.
Received: Lounge access.

I was also the victim of a violent assault in the lounge which the hotel did nothing about. Management simply did not care and did not even answer my request for assistance to identify the culprit or to file a police report. Attitudes are very indifferent at this hotel - stay away.
 
12 nights at the Courtyard Hong Kong Sha Tin as a Gold.

received upgrade to Premier room with River view and breakfast in the restaurant for 2.

excellent service on-site and they make the location work with their shuttle into ICC and TST stations.
 
Status: Gold
Property: Zurich Marriott
Booked: Superior Twin, Main Building
Upgraded: Nil. Not even a room with a river view.
Received: Lounge access.

I was also the victim of a violent assault in the lounge which the hotel did nothing about. Management simply did not care and did not even answer my request for assistance to identify the culprit or to file a police report. Attitudes are very indifferent at this hotel - stay away.

Say what? What happened?
 
Say what? What happened?

On the morning of check-out, after a final leisurely stroll across the river to the park near the hotel, I returned to the hotel and visited the executive lounge to get a bottle of water from the fridge to drink in the room before finishing packing and then checking out. Whilst I was patiently queueing in line in front of the fridge, as soon as I got to the front and as I was reaching down to grab a bottle, suddenly from my right side a male guest violently shoved me out of the way.

This was a violent aggressive assault which knocked me off balance and also caused me to fall over. Even worse was the fact I was holding a glass bottle in my hand at the time and this could have easily been dropped or gone flying and shattered everywhere. Children were in the lounge so this could have been quite dangerous.



Shocked by the fact I had just been assaulted, I asked the man for an apology but instead the only reply I received was "**** you".

Concerned for my safety and not wanting to be violently assaulted again, I decided to leave the lounge. Meanwhile, the male lounge attendant made eye contact with me but did and said nothing. Eventually I said that he should bring the violent man into line and maintain standards of behaviour. No reply was forthcoming, although the violent thug started shouting foul language again.

Finally I noticed that about 25mins later, as I loaded my suitcase into the car to take me to the airport, the violent criminal was smoking in front of the hotel. He again made a violent gesture towards me and mouthed the words "**** you".


I took a photo of the criminal smoking in front of the hotel and send it, together with an email setting out the full facts, to the hotel and seeking their help to investigate and for contact details to file a police report. Initially I did this via the Marriott app (the concierge always answered instantly with other requests - this time I simply asked for the GM or hotel's email address). I was asked why I needed the email address and I then said I had been assaulted and needed to send a photo of the attacker (a fellow guest who was therefore a danger to everyone in the hotel) but the message was ignored and the concierge then left the conversation - I have the phone screenshots to prove this.

Through Google I found the GM's email so sent everything in. Got the out of office reply but it contained his deputy's email for urgent matters so I sent it to her.

Silence for 48 hours and all I received was a vague assurance that this was an isolated incident and a thank you for reporting the matter to them. No attempt at service recovery, and my questions about identifying the culprit, or to send me the contact details for the local police, among others, were all completely ignored. Rather miffed I then emailed Marriott HQ. They bounced the matter back to the hotel who told me that they did not get involved in "disputes" between guests, ignoring the fact that there was never any dispute and I was simply the victim of a random attack. Again, another empty apology and an offer to give me the police contact details if I wanted them (despite my first email clearly asking for them). Still no service recovery and just a pathetically expressed hope I would stay with them again and give them a second chance.

By the way, the animal smoking in the photo below is the thug who attacked me. If you see him, beware he may randomly attack you.IMG_6436.jpg
 
What a terrible story. The lounge agent not acting on this immediately is plain wrong. I wonder if the asshole in question is some big-wig or otherwise known to the hotel.
 
What a terrible story. The lounge agent not acting on this immediately is plain wrong. I wonder if the asshole in question is some big-wig or otherwise known to the hotel.

Yeah - very poor service from Zurich Marriott. I have also noticed that Marriotts make themselves difficult to contact by not having any email information on the hotel website at all - whereas for SPG hotels the website always has email details which can be easily found. Says a lot about the difference in culture between the two organisations.
 
Yeah - very poor service from Zurich Marriott. I have also noticed that Marriotts make themselves difficult to contact by not having any email information on the hotel website at all - whereas for SPG hotels the website always has email details which can be easily found. Says a lot about the difference in culture between the two organisations.

You could send an email to here, [email protected] and CC [email protected] and then see how long the scramble to make contact with you takes? If none, then take your business elsewhere. I have always found them to be very customer focused in the past.
 
Had a couple of Marriott stays as GO in July, most properties went above and beyond but one was truly a disaster.
Was at CY HK-ST twice and both stays were awesome. Upgraded to suites on both stays, late checkout til 4pm was given without asking, lounge was great (though service can be hit and miss). I tend to have breakfast upstairs at the lounge due to better food quality and service there, whereas the restaurant downstairs can be a zoo. Evening snacks at lounge can almost resemble a dinner, so that's always good.

REN-HKT was the highlight of the four stays. Upgraded to a oceanfront pool villa there, some snacks/pastries each afternoon, breakfast was AWESOME. Great variety from Asian to western options, including ehm... some bloody mary, icecream and a great assortment of fruit. The food there was really really great quality, and since the breakfast was til 11am, you can pretty much skip lunch and look for some snacks at tea time. Everyone there was very nice and helpful, elite recognition was great too. In more than one occasion, the room was quietly made up/cleaned up once I left the room, and the snacks were always delivered shortly after we arrived at the villa. Our preference for seats/drinks/room number was remembered by the staff member the second morning we had breakfast at the restaurant. You can really feel the level of commitment they have for guest services, and you certainly know they always keep an eye on you without impeding your privacy. The only thing I would bug about is the location of the resort, it's kinda remote and there's basically not much dining choices close to the resort.
 
Back
Top